Covid-19 origins: plain speaking is overdue
thelancet.com
thelancet.com
Actually, to the layman on the street, both origins are reasonable, according to common sense.
Everyone's made a slip up at work before. We have prior examples of labs accidentally leaking biological materials before. That lab happened to be experimenting with the same type of viruses as corona. It also happened to be right next to where the first cases emerged. And after, the authorities wouldn't allow an investigation.
You'd have to be out of your mind to not view that as a plausible origin.
If you think there's reasons that isn't the origin, and you've proof it definitely came straight from the jungle, the professional approach is just to keep presenting your case. Not having a tantrum like a little child because other people are maintaining opinions different to yours.
1) Natural origin, natural transmission to humans.
2) Natural origin, sampled for the lab an escaped.
3) Artificial origin in the lab (like a genetic modification) and then escaped.
4) Evil artificial origin and on purpose release.
Ignoring 4), one of the problem is that people mix 2) and 3). I read many post with "proofs" of 3) that were debunked one week later, and then people claimed that it also debunked 2).
Disclaimer: I think there are many similar cases of 1), like a covirus local epidemic every 10 years, or a flu variant every 5 years, so for me 1) is the natural explanation.
From the article:
> In the USA in particular, they have produced amateurish reports that have even misrepresented work published in The Lancet Microbe.
They are angry because people (they don't like) is misquoting them in the Internet. It's very common to be misquoted (if you are famous enough) and it's very common to get angry about that.
Inevitably, due to world events, people are going to be suddenly become curious about things that only experts previously cared about. They’re going to need explainers that go beyond the basics, however deep they want to go.
That sentence up there is a comment from HN during the 2016 election - based off of nothing more than hearsay and nonsensical allegations, in a thread of much the same. Go read it yourselves it’s probably the #1 thread about him on HN. Emotionally charged drivel in an ocean of.
SA title was right - the internet does make you stupid.
https://tildes.net/~misc/1hof/the_rise_of_strategic_corrupti...
This seems like kind of a weirdly dismissive take. Is the idea that a lab in China lacked proper implantation of safety protocols really that "fanciful"?
After leaking from the lab, it was extremely deadly at first and this was made worse by the overuse of ventilators. It gradually mutated into basically another virus that causes the common cold over the course of 2 years.
It will likely remain an extremely controversial topic and I doubt there will be an objective history of the pandemic period within our lifetimes. It became a culture war issue and each side dug in on their respective positions, facts be damned.
Also SARS-CoV-2 lineages are still much more deadly and cause many more hospitalizations than the common cold. They haven’t magically mutated to be less significant, those who survived have more and wider spread partial immunity and we have, over time, developed better treatment protocols. In a hundred years or more SARS-CoV-2 won’t be killing a significant number of the elderly and the immune-compromised every year, but right now it’s still a leading reaper.
Can anyone see author information that I am missing?
This is extremely common practice in print journalism, and has been for centuries.
An email to editorial@lancet.com with reference to the DOI will get you through to the author(s).