Mandating that would also mean the 3rd party also would have to take responsibility that the updated software conforms to spec and doesn't kill someone. Who's going to pay for that?
Mandating that would also mean the 3rd party also would have to take responsibility that the updated software conforms to spec and doesn't kill someone. Who's going to pay for that?
Besides it's not like people have only "swapped parts". People have basically entirely rebuilt engines and many other systems in the car. You are underselling what what has commonly always been done.
So yeah, I don't really feel like you've answered my original question:
> Haven't third parties been repairing cars for all automotive history?
Software 'repair' consists of managing thousands of dependencies and building new firmware from scratch. Modern cars contain a lot of mandatory safety systems, from ABS to emergency braking, pedestrian detection, emergency SOS calls, active steering with lane assist, speeding notifications, driver fatigue detection etc. Knowing how software companies operate, I presume they got it just about working per spec. I don't know if you can expect a third party to manage such a complex stack and update it in a way that's up to spec and satisfies all legal requirements. And even if that's possible I don't think it will be cheaper anyway. Computers are a very different world, just as car manufacturers are still discovering.