A more accurate analogy would be that without looking at very much sand, you already possess one grain of sand in the exact shape of your face. This spikes your curiosity and you ask: What are the chances of finding another?
I do think these are two different arguments.
1. Aliens can exist because we exist
2. Aliens do exist because of probabilities
Mine was about 2
I think it would be orders of magnitude more astounding if aliens didn't exist than if they did, just given the sheer odds of life only happening once in the observable universe. That's all I'm saying.
There probably is one though right? depending on how you define similarity
Holy straw-man.
Funny, no-one said straw-man when I had these discussion in philosophy studies at university. Looks like there are different people on HN than those studying philosophy. Learned something!