I guess one way the observer could send us information without violating the conservation of energy would be by varying the quantum noise (decreasing energy in one region of the field and equally increasing it somewhere else).
I guess one way the observer could send us information without violating the conservation of energy would be by varying the quantum noise (decreasing energy in one region of the field and equally increasing it somewhere else).
So on a long enough timespan, sufficient control of the inside of the simulation could promote arbitrary action outside of it - a trivial example being convincing the observer to make the connection 2-way.
Which is what AI escape scenarios, incidentally, are all about. Lock the AI in a box, and just watch it: how long before it would, even by accident, manipulate the observer to think "we need to talk to it" and open the box?
Assuming plausible, now imagine it is actually using a Hashlife-like implementation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashlife). E.g. the implementation does not actually compute all time steps in sequence. Instead, it leaps strides here and there and whoever "runs" it can rewind time to any point (yes, this idea was explored in Permutation City).
Now question 1: in this setup, what does communicating with observer even mean? https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/math/a16593584/tupp...
Now imagine implementation has a bug, that allows the simulated universe to perform arbitrary code execution. How real is this simulated universe (or more really like observed) with a chance to break out vs a simulated universe that runs on a bug free simulation software?
The most annoying thing about Permutation City is that it intentionally disregards complexity. Generally in simulation it will be possible to speed up many types of computation, but there will be many computations that will be impossible to speed up, even some of simplest cellular automata are like that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computational_irreducibility
Does it really? I get the same vibes as when people talk about "observing" in a quantum context, and then assume there must be a sentient entity involved.
In a cosmology sufficiently weird that everything we know is a simulation, what's to say that random simulations aren't just a thing that happens?
In the purest meaning of the word, a simulation is the imitation of something which, in my opinion, means that there is a sentient intention for imitating a certain behavior. I don't think a random similitude can be considered a simulation.
If our Universe just randomly runs inside another bigger Universe without any sentient entity involved, and we consider that a "simulation", then the Moon orbiting the Earth is also a simulation of the Earth orbiting the Sun... and at that point the word "simulation" loses all useful meaning.