A Texas DNA Lab Cracked the 1995 Murder of Catherine Edwards
texasmonthly.com
texasmonthly.com
I am surprised they did this. I imagine DNA evidence trumps the cuffs as evidence, but still.. That's just begging for the DA to make some bogus claim based on technicalities.
Imagine you're condemned to prison because you sat on the same train as a soon to be murder-victim, and your dandruff landed on their clothing.
Each and every step you've outlined is utterly insane to me.
And just like social media, it doesn’t matter if you refuse to play. All it takes is any of your friends to allow them to scrape their address book and bingo, you are now a part of the social graph, like it or not.
Law enforcement doesn’t need your DNA. They just need the DNA of anyone related to you, which according to this article can include any one of thousands of people.
Privacy is truly dead.
Absolutely agreed; however, all it takes it that one "doesn't care why should you?!" -brother / genetic relative... to get your partial genetic information into the hands of profiteering geneticists / admen.
The fuck?! Why, dearest brother James..?
Of course, I live in the real world and not a delusional paranoiac realm of fearmongering so I realize that the tangible realizable benefits far outweigh any, even hypothetical, risks.
As far as risks, literally being falsely imprisoned or executed is an actual, real world risk, that people have actually experienced. https://daily.jstor.org/forensic-dna-evidence-can-lead-wrong...
There is also a chance, however small, that a genealogical genetic match to me will lead to one of my trashy drug-addicted relatives going to jail for rape.
>literally being falsely imprisoned or executed is an actual, real world risk, that people have actually experienced
The article you yourself linked to, which I read every word of, contains no examples of people "literally being falsely imprisoned or executed".
Eyewitness testimony can lead to false imprisonment-- is the solution to ban eyewitness testimony?
Finding a suspect's fingerprint at a scene can lead to false imprisonment-- is the solution to ban fingerprints?
DNA evidence is only a single link in a long chain and has all of the benefits and drawbacks of fingerprints, eyewitness testimony, and all other forms of evidence. It is no different, despite what crime shows might have you think.
Every time you're feeling stressed out about the jackbooted gubmint thugz locking you up if they find your DNA somewhere just repeat to yourself "it's the exact same thing as them finding a fingerprint or CCTV still, just newer".
"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury we found the suspect's fingerprints and DNA at the scene, have a CCTV image of him buying the hammer that has his fingerprints and DNA on it, and have three eyewitnesses who saw him enter the scene of the crime right before the murder"
"Throw it all out, it's a conspiracy, a violation of the defendant's rights. That's all faulty evidence fraught with peril and allowing it will destroy democracy and freedom as we know it."
You sure are putting a whole lot of words in my mouth. I’m going to assume you are no longer engaging in good faith. Enjoy your impending future data leak.
I want everyone to have my DNA information.
It cannot be used to harm me.
I have already actually and literally given it away. You yourself can download it.
And I don't need to lie about what an article contains to try and scare people.
Like you did.
You stopped acting in good faith the moment you lied.
You lied about the content of the link you posted, probably thinking that I wouldn't read it. But I did read it, the link YOU YOURSELF posted, and I discovered you lying about what it contained.
Because you are a liar.
And I respond to liars with ridicule.
edit: note to the civility police-- none of the above statements are personal attacks, they are statements of fact based on evidence posted directly by the person being responded to of his or her own free will, available for public observation on a website designed to allow for responses. The person I am responding to is irrefutably and unquestionably a liar who lied about the content of a link he or she posted. It was not a mistake, omission, misinterpretation, or anything else-- it was a lie.
I have a friend who volunteers to go through dental records for kidnapped children, trying to locate the records for the body of the found child. These are the types of things people don’t usually think about. And if you’re curious, yes, sometimes kidnappers even destroy the teeth to try and prevent the identification of the children.
These aren’t just to solve crimes, but locate family members of the deceased John/Jane Does.
And this is whole para is shocking:
> According to the case file, Foreman, then a 21-year-old Nabisco salesman, had been driving through Beaumont when he saw a young woman who’d had car trouble. Foreman stopped to offer her a ride, claiming to be a cop. He drove the woman to a secluded area, threatened to cut her throat with a knife, tied her hands behind her back with a belt, and raped her. About two weeks later, the traumatized woman went to the police. Foreman readily confessed, explaining that he had “been out drinking and just got carried away.” In exchange for pleading guilty to aggravated assault, he received three years of probation. Aaron soon learned that Foreman and Edwards were three years apart at Forest Park High School. Edwards and her twin sister, Allison, had even been bridesmaids at Foreman’s 1982 wedding.
YUCK