"Why It's a Bad Idea to Tell Students Words Are Violence : A claim increasingly heard on campus will make them more anxious and more willing to justify physical harm." (2017)
https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/07/why-it...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonviolent_Communication
Coercion -> force -> violence
Forcing ads onto kids = violence?
Speaking clearly sometimes means saying things that are uncomfortable to hear.
Non-violent communication isn't at all about manipulation. It's about discussing behaviors and their impact on the person vs attacking and defending in circles that go nowhere.
It's just that in practice I've only seen it used by morons to shut down discussions they don't feel like having.
You can’t make people harmless, but you can force them to innovate different ways to harm others.
It's much darker.
The fact is that exactly the same people who are pushing the idea, are the ones who we would need protection from. And they're not innovating much, it's the same bs over and over and over again.
Perhaps a slightly reductive view, but I see “NVC” as basically saying that when people argue, emotions can sometimes overrule logic.
When people get emotional, they sometimes plug their ears and start screaming into the void.
NVC is then basically a bunch of tactics to circumvent the emotional aspect so that the discussion can get back to logical facts.
It also tries to create a framework where the people arguing have to hear the other side’s arguments before making a counter argument.
I think the book has some very useful ideas mixed in with some amount of self-promotion. I think the name “Nonviolent Communication” (which might throw some people off) is part of that self-promotion. Don’t let the name fool you.
We're already at the point where we're almost not supposed to have emotions anymore, turning more into robots every day.
Every single aspect of being human is emotional, every single decision you make is emotional, no matter how hard you work to justify it mentally.
The idea is nice in theory, if it wasn't for all the humans involved it might actually work.
A possible compromise that might work is to protect _good faith_ speech while working against bad faith speech.