Apollo involved almost half a million people. You cannot manage that on gut feel.
We're not saying you have to personally know 500k people. We're saying that to some people, it's very clear and obvious that someone working for them is incompetent and/or simply doing a bad job (and this is not gut feel). This shouldn't be up for debate or controversy. If you hired that person to manage another person, you expect them to know what they're doing and at the very least see the Red Flags of incompetence (whatever they may be). We've been trying the "systemic" way of ridding ourselves of bias, but here it is, alive and well. What we got instead is a broken system that's full of conflicting priorities and people trying their best to navigate them and doing so badly - all whilst the actual goals and priorities get sidelined as secondary.
We can either choose excellence and competence, or we get this weird mediocrity that is killing us slowly but somehow we can say "but it's running our large department based on science and scalable metrics".
Maybe we're not supposed to make these departments scale, maybe we need to keep them small and autonomous and "unfair" to some degree in order to function. Have we considered that? Not everything has to be optimized to the N-th degree and made to grow large like an instagram or google.
https://www.dw.com/en/berlins-new-airport-finally-opens-a-st...
https://www.reuters.com/article/world/late-and-overweight-ge...
And sure, does that mean Bob might get it wrong? Of course, he might even be a petty little tyrant with an ego or he just might not like Steve because he made a funny comment about Bob's tie on his first day. I don't think some things can scale and be optimized away like we're all a bunch of cogs in a machine with our own individual little tasks and performance metrics that get aggregated into the larger whole.
The commander essentially says that he constantly receives conflicting reports about his leaders' performance, and if he relieved one for unproven reports, his command would disintegrate. Because the good leaders have equal numbers of bad reports about them, from those who don't like them.
Summed up the proper exercise of authority nicely, imho.
The alternative is developing an intuition for bullshit. It's rarer, but I've had a few non-technical PMs / managers who were excellent at their job because they could suss out whether someone wasn't being honest.
And it's great if a handful of people can smell out bs in a field they're not familiar with, but you can't write policy on the back of a few unicorns like that. (Yes, managing ego is hard too, but I believe it's more common to start with and more trainable.)
Once it's common for someone in authority to tiebreak on technical arguments, it becomes very important they can set their ego aside.