It is much more frequent for -ffast-math to generate bigger errors than to benefit from an accidental cancellation of the errors.
The only case when the result of underflows is predictable is when the values whose computation may result in an underflow are immediately added to other values that are known to be big enough, and they are not used for anything else.
It is not frequent to have so much information about which expressions will underflow and which will not, and about the range of possible values of the values that would be added. When there really exists so much information about what must be computed, then there are chances that the computation can be rearranged in a way that would avoid the underflows, in which case there would be no need to change MXCSR to ignore the underflows, because they would not happen.