What’s Another $14 Billion Anyway?
mattmaroon.com
mattmaroon.com
Additionally there are costs to compliance, and those are probably going to be greater at car companies (that have factories, dealers, financing divisions, etc, etc). The car companies have tighter margins and more costs to meet compliance. Banks move numbers around, not physical objects - their compliance could, and should, cost less.
I'm opposed to both of the bailouts, with or without oversight.
So you're fine with the government taking your money (i.e. your property) and giving it to someone outside of the government for no reason other than "they're a big company"?
I'm totally open-minded on this issue, so I'd love to hear a well-reasoned argument as to why it made sense for the government to have done that. As it stands, I feel that it is quite immortal to redistribute property unjustly.
I don't consider myself informed enough to have a strong opinion about the $700 billion one.
They're playing poker with your chips. Isn't it worthwhile to understand their tactics (or lack of tactics)?
Is that a good idea? I really can't say for sure. The theory sounds good, but for all I know its misguided.
It's not worthwhile for me to try to determine that for myself. I don't have years to devote to the study of economics, which would be necessary for me to have an informed opinion on whether or not the loans will prevent far more than they cost. We can't all be economists, and anyone who isn't can't have an informed opinion. And even if I did have that kind of time, by the time I got that far it would be too late. And even then, the most informed opinions are still far from infallible. They're significantly more likely to be correct than the one I have now for sure, and they're the best we can do, but I'm not sure how much my one extra vote would matter.
That's the thing with government and capitalism, it's all about division of labor. I can't be informed about everything. I just try to vote for people who will get advice from people who are, which is why I base my votes more on a candidate's intelligence and epistemology than their stances and specialized issues such as economics..
I'd never buy an American car, and it has nothing to do with the price. They're ugly, and crap. End of story.
Well, I try to scoot around the issue asking for "anything japanese", or german, etc etc
If you get saddled with an American car, it can only go in straight lines, and probably has a big sofa as the front seats. They're just ridiculously bad cars. It's like they froze time in the 50s and kept making cars exactly the same.
I defy any one of the big three to release a minivan comparable to the Toyota Sienna for anywhere near the same price (+$2k is fine).
And why does inexpensive have to mean low quality? From what little I know, the Japanese manufacturing mindset (read: The Toyota Way) is that high quality equals lower cost over the long haul.
You're talking 10-20% of the manufacturing cost of the car in an industry that has spent 100 years reducing costs in every conceivable way. There isn't that sort of slack laying around. The only way to recoup that cost is to use significantly inferior parts.
My next blog post will address that a bit. It's already written, just hasn't published yet.
Still, it's far deeper than wages and costs.
What about the costs to the company for the warranty repairs? The big 3 were offering some very long term warranties for a while. If the sort of quality you are talking about is durability, that could end up increasing costs.
The big 3 approach to reducing costs has been inferior to the Toyota approach. The restrictive UAW work rules limit the flexibility of the work force and devalue overall productivity. They should compare the throughput and excess inventory of the manufacturers. You will see that GM makes too much too slowly, and thus can't respond to demand in a pull based manner as well as Toyota.
The money should go to startup car companies. BYD is valued at 2.5B and they have a huge cell phone battery business. For 15B we could easily start 10 car companies. Invest in the real future.
With the bailout, all that pressure is gone. The only real way GM et al. have a way of pressuring the UAW now is to convince the UAW that they are willing to go out of business to turn a profit... no longer a credible threat because the next congress will happily bail out the UAW for the chance to waste more money on "green cars" (Ie. overpriced cars that nobody wants).
Toyota and the other foreign manufacturers were careful never to become too dependent on unions and they are also not subject to the two fleet requirements (too much, they are careful to skirt them) of the CAFE regulations thus giving them a credible bargaining chip against unions like the UAW when negotiations are necessary. For more info, see http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122584326266699163.html
Have you compared the big three and their Japanese rivals in terms of their manufacturing process?
And The Toyota Way was published 5 years ago and was a snapshot of the industry years before that. I promise you people at GM have read it too. I wouldn't deny that Toyota has probably done better until more recently, and that their actions therefore gave them more than the $2,000 edge. But $2,000 is more than enough to win.
I'm not trying to suggest that that $2,000 is the only problem, just that it's one that is insurmountable, and therefore needs to be fixed.
Crap, maybe, but not ugly. I find it hard to believe that the complicated ugly of US cars is less costly to manufacture than the clean lines of a VW. I think it's far more likely that the people deciding who designs what and what designs make it to production have no taste.
Ford trends better at design than the other two. Is that because they don't suffer as much extra cost, or because they're just more competent?
If this is really the case than the US government should have agreed to some sort of specific bailout for the health care and benefits wages which are really dragging these companies down. If Toyota can work with US labor (well kind of, see source below) than there is no reason that the big three should not be able to.
Interesting side story. Toyota is worried because "Labor costs as a percentage of sales are growing faster than Toyota's profit margin" and there is now talk of unionizing to sustain labor wages. One of their own senior employees is quoted as saying, "I'm more than willing to work with that company to keep my job. But when they just take it because they want more, I don't agree with it at all." (http://www.freep.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2008112120001)
If Toyota gets caught up in this UAW mess too, I'm not sure how any company will produce in the US. Is there any foreseeable way jobs can stay here if the unions won't let the companies operate profitably?
More attention should be re-diverted back to the banks...
What does Matt Maroon do for a living?