Prometheus Unbound: What The Movie Was Actually About | Hacker News Reader

Prometheus Unbound: What The Movie Was Actually About

cavalorn.livejournal.com

30 pointsmirceagoia10 comments

Yes there is a lot of depth to Prometheus, this makes me only hate it more. If Prometheus were just a silly horror film or a comic book movie then I'd be ok with it being mediocre.

Instead, they poured an immense amount of design skill into the sets and backgrounds to make a wonderfully beautiful movie. And they built up this tremendous premise and a fantastic universe. And they populated it with several truly deep and rich and wonderful characters. And they had those characters acted by outrageously talented actors (Charlize Theron, Michael Fassbender, Idris Elba, Guy Pierce).

And then they pissed it all away with a shoddy plot and incompetent direction.

Spoilers follow:

The engineer turns out to just be a dime store monster. Nobody's actions are interesting, meaningful, or seem to flow from any significant motive other than to conform to the plot. One of the most dramatic scenes in the movie (when Janek decides to commit suicide by ramming the engineer's ship) comes off as completely anti-climactic because it comes out of nowhere. Similarly, the major revelation of the movie of the planet being a biowarfare research station comes out of Janek's mouth but it is so out of place and out of character that you can almost hear the clanking boilerplate of dreaded exposition falling into position. Perhaps the most interesting character of the entire movie, David, remains nothing more than an automaton throughout the movie with only a gnat's whisker of a hint that he is anything more.

Prometheus the fictional spaceship is a "trillion dollar" mission which is unaccountably staffed by a handful of incompetents, fuckups, and pseudo-villains who throw away their lives for the silliest and least meaningful of reasons. It is an apt metaphor for the movie itself.

I completely agree. The movie was absolutely beautiful, but the plot towards the end seemed really forced.

Spoilers:

It seemed to go downhill as soon as Elizabeth found out she was pregnant and escaped the room she was in to have that machine remove it. Shortly after, Janek is telling Elizabeth about the planet being a research station without acknowledging what happened to her at all. From what I can remember, not one person mentioned it. She even had to knock out people to escape the room, if I remember correctly.

For me it was even earlier, when they casually re-animated a 2000-year-old mummified head with what appeared to be a Taser, then promptly forgot they had that technology for the rest of the film.

That's the thing about this movie, they do things like make first contact with the only alien life mankind has ever met or reanimate a centuries old alien head and each event is about as monumental as reading the morning paper.

Indeed. I forgot to mention "basic continuity errors and the characters doing fundamentally stupid things."

Elizabeth has a knock down drag out fight with several crew members, then has an alien fetus removed by a robo doctor machine. But it's fine, nobody else even comments about it later, and the people she fought with and ran away from seem to have forgotten it happened.

Similarly, when 2 people get attacked by mutated worm creatures the rest of the crew needs to investigate in person. You know, because the equipment on a trillion dollar starship that's been monitoring suit cameras and basic health functions lacks basic DVR features and wasn't designed to sound an alarm when someone dies or their heartbeat indicates a medical emergency. Just plain dumb at a foundational level.

I´m not necessarily defending the movie, but I don´t think that Janek actually "solved" it, but I do think that that´s what they want us to believe. The black goo is not an weapon IMHO, but a way to accelerate the evolutionary process in a planet, bringing forth more adaptable lifeforms (without preserving the previous ones). That´s what is shown in the beginning of the movie. The engineers could be responsible for rapid evolutionary bursts throughout the history of our and other worlds.

Perhaps we, as a species, weren´t simply done yet. Something still had to burst out our collective chests in order for us to actualize our genetic potential. Maybe the xenomorphs were the ultimate monkeys out of which the definitive mankind would evolve from.

Piss poor execution though.

Have to disagree with this. It's an interesting attempt at criticism, but I think it's stretching too far.

What Prometheus is "actually about" is sucking dollars out of moviegoers' wallets.

For many years Ridley Scott resisted the calls to revisit the "Alien" universe, and when he finally gave in he produced a shallow, overly-marketed, slickly commercial film that looks great but lacks a soul. We've seen this before: the Star Wars prequels (which disappointed fans also tried to analyze and criticize into something more meaningful).

Prometheus was a dud; let's just accept that and go watch "Alien" on Blu-Ray.

Production cost: 130 millions. Worldwide boxoffice so far: 217 millions

That's a good "dud".

Prometheus seem to be that kind of movie you need to see several times to understand it.

I got the sense that things were left intentionally vague -- not so much to make the movie a mind-bending philosophical exercise, but more as a storytelling cop-out and a way to guarantee a sequel:

http://www.movies.com/movie-news/ridley-scott-prometheus-int...

So I wouldn't count on understanding too much more on multiple viewings...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com