Hacker News Reader

Comment by overtomanu | Hacker News Reader

There is a post on reddit by the author

Bold 0.2 - An IDE with LSP, DAP and more : programming

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1eupocr/bold_0...

He is getting a lot of hate there for not open-sourcing it. I noticed a very hostile environment for one-person projects that don't do everything open-source, while businesses aren't held to the same standard, and they are the ones that benefit the most. That's sad.

Large buisnesses ars less likely to deploy malware on your PC, they have reputation, contrary to some random programmer on the internet

Are they? VSCode is literally a malware with all the telemetry and it is opensource.

Hyperbole kills the meaning of words, to the point that people stop taking them seriously. You're doing a disservice to "malware" here. Yes, VSCode wants to know everything you do in that app, but it's not like it will keylog everything you do and steal your credit card.

That's no hyperbole. Do you know what a malware is? If you do, you know that a text editor that collects telemetry is a type of malware, period. There is no meaning discussing if they are logging every thing but if they can. If they can, it is a malware. They can.

You know about VSCodium, right? No telemetry.

Earlier thread seems more well received:

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1c8yhll/i_cant...

"I can't stand using vscode so I wrote my own". I suppose that explains the motivation and the intended audience.

> He is getting a lot of hate there for not open-sourcing it.

We have very different definitions of "hate". I mean, some posts are mildly negative, but there's nothing there that could be described as hate.

The word "hate" is often hyperbolized in online discourse.

It's not unfair. I have a different standard for proprietary payware and proprietary freeware. With the former, you know where you stand, but in my experience, the reasons for not releasing freeware under a FOSS licence are normally user-hostile, like baiting in users with a free product and charging money once they're hooked. I've been bitten too many times, so I don't tend to install proprietary freeware anymore.

He should go with just naming it "Bold." Not "Bold Edit", just "Bold." Not be all Sean Parker, but that seems obvious to me.

I kind of agree, shorter is sweeter.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com