Harris has the right idea on housing
noahpinion.blog
noahpinion.blog
P.S. I'm not suggesting stimulus checks weren't necessary, just the effects weren't desirable long term.
> A first time home owner credit helps, but most of the credit will be absorbed by the market in the form of increased home prices.
The article addresses this concern with an evaluation of the policy in Singapore. A 9.8% increase in home purchases comes with a 1.1% increase in price. We don't have any way to know the effect of the policy in the US, but it's hard to understand why the only effect would be a higher price.
California saw a 7.4% increase in median sale price when the number of purchase were down 8% in June of 2024. We shouldn’t be using what worked in Singapore as an indicator of what will work here. https://www.redfin.com/state/California/housing-market
In the English speaking world houses are a financial asset. In Singapore houses are homes to live in.
No matter how many condos and houses you build they will be bought by speculators.
A lot of the QE since 2008 went in buying assets which includes houses. Now the Fed is trying to shrink the money supply.
This is true only in nominal terms. Shelter is the largest expense for most Americans, an across-the-board rise in shelter cost would drive significant inflation.
Most of the money over the last 20 years has just gone into Asset purchases, little into in productive activities. Hence the asset price inflation.
Local municipalities adopt building codes that are so stringent as if you were building some kind of nuclear bunker, and local builders/developers happily use it as an excuse to gouge potential home-buyers to extract the absolute maximum they are willing to pay.
Let people build what they want on their land. Someone wants to build an ADU in their backyard? Let them. Let them do it shoddily if they want.
Building more is 90% of driving down costs.
Isn't that the new plan? I'm not partisan on this, I understand that some Americans didn't like the fact that it remove local power do forbid new construction.
Centralisation/decentralization is a complex issue and I don't have the knowledge to have an informed opinion.
When certain people raised the alarm about foreign buyers buying up the supply the charge of racism was trotted out to shut them up, even when the person raising the alarm was of the same race as those buying.
Housing is now an Asset and all its problems of affordability derive from that.
A lot of people are assuming supply is the problem.
Personally I wold also down vote it as it is not very well founded. A change of the wording would probably go a long way not to be down-voted and also some support for the ideas.
Furthermore, it represents a sentiment and a direction I think most people on HN do not agree with. As a European I also do not not agree that direction to solve the issue.
My take is there are some active YIMBY groups in SF in particular, and for some reason they are strongly and actively disliked by a lot of the local HN crowd- but they generally don't seem to want to say anything about it or explain why. I'm not informed enough to know what is actually going on, as I don't live there, but have been accused of being part of specific groups in specific places that I know nothing about when I've posted.
Also though, most of the issues they raised (e.g. zoning, permitting, fees, property and sales taxes, demographic sales restrictions [I'm gonna need a cite on that one]) are municipal and state government concerns and not particularly relevant or actionable at the federal level.
> Cut Red Tape and Needless Bureaucracy. These plans will build on the Biden-Harris Administration's efforts to cut red tape and enable more home building to bring down housing costs-which have advanced record levels of new home construction. Pushing this forward also means streamlining permitting processes and reviews, including for transit-oriented and conversion development, so builders canget homes on the market sooner and bring down costs.
streamline permitting
knock down ridiculous fees and paperwork
don't try to tax the builder out of business
don't put stupid mandates about forcing builders to sell to demographics the current administration prefers
basically, get out of the way and homes will be built
Lumber prices are back to pre-pandemic levels (wholesale).
There's never been a higher amount of immigrant labor available in the US (for construction as well).
While immigration has increased, it hasn't increased at a rate to replace Americans leaving the labor market. Overall, the amount of labor in the United States has decreased. That dramatically impacts labor-intensive industries, such as construction.
So, we're still faced with a high cost of materials and a shortage of labor.
But most of the building restrictions are coming conservative older homeowners at the local level. There's only so much Harris can do at the Federal level to reduce state and county bureaucracy.
It terms of population, liberal towns seem to be the culprit.