Should the Obama Generation Drop Out?
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
1) The cultural reason. A lot of politics is cultural; most people have a self image, and pick a party to fit that image. The self image of Obama's party: smart/educated/cultured, not to mention altruistic. Providing education is viewed as a morally virtuous act ("give something back", with "in return for money and excellent job security" being unstated), not merely a professional choice.
De-emphasize education? Sacrilege. It's like suggesting a religious conservative should de-emphasize traditional hetero marriage. Good luck with that.
2) It goes strongly against the interests of Obama and his party: http://www.opensecrets.org/pres08/select.php?ind=W04
University isn't about job training, no matter how some people might want it to be. It's not about what you learn, it's about learning to learn.
But, since our job is also not to support the LCD but the GCD, I would still support this. I would have taken more Japanese, or possibly another language, if I didn't have to take Geology. I likely would have also substituted more Philosophy for Communications. That would have been a better supplement to my CS coursework and wouldn't have made me a less well-rounded person.
I could've done a much better job in my Computer Science 101/102 courses if I could just teach the people who really wanted to study the material, and not people who just wanted to get out of the math requirement.
OTOH, he is correct that BA degrees have little relevance in the modern economy. They persist as a relic from the role liberal-arts colleges played before WW2 in conferring educational pedigrees on upper-class men. Higher education is much more egalitarian today, but we're still aping the educational practices of that era.
As a general rule, I don't think anyone should spend the time or money on a degree that they aren't going to use after graduation.
Or, nobody _should_ be forcing anybody to get a bachelor's degree. It should be completely up to the kid going through the schooling to make up their own mind.
I can't tell you how many times I've gotten stuff (work, tips, useful stuff, etc) not through my schooling but through the people I know, but I'm still going through my bachelor's degree/master's degree hopefully a few of these/PhD because I want to.
If you don't like what you're doing, do something else while you're still young. You most likely have a place to live (parents) and some form of ambition, but if you decide to go through a useless bachelor's degree (I'm not saying that bachelor's degrees are useless, just getting an unused bachelor's degree is) that's your problem and you don't have the right to complain. Just do something about it!
Lots of young people are turned out of home when they reach adult age. I wouldn't assume that any particular nineteen-year-old has anywhere else to live but a place where he is paying rent.
I'm 30 and I've never met or heard of one in the last fifteen years or so. I'm sure such young people exist, but I doubt there are "lots" of them anymore.
What circles do you hang out in?
I'm considerably older, and perhaps I've lived in more different places too.
Disagree strongly. Most people are too undisciplined to get through the "hard" majors, or too uninterested to get through the "softer" ones (e.g. engineers who claim they couldn't have done a history major).
I agree that not everyone should be going to college. A proportion higher than 10% doesn't make sense to me. However, I'd guess that 20-40% have enough raw intellectual ability to pass through college with decent grades, and that 5-10% could complete virtually any major. The important point is that, although a quarter or more have the intellectual mettle to get through college, they have no interest in the coursework, and are going through the motions only to be employable.
I'll also point out that American college students are not working full-throttle. At demanding colleges (Ivies, MIT, top LACs) they might average 30-40 hours per week on classes and homework. At "average" colleges-- filled mostly by students who don't belong there for reasons of motivation (to get a job) rather than ability-- it's closer to 10-20.
Not true, at least as you state it. When I was at MIT, I was spending about 30-40 hours per week on homework for a single class. Not all my classes were this hard, but there was at least one ball-buster per term. And I was far from alone in this regard.
Amherst was usually about 20-30 hours/week between classes and homework, except when I took Quantum Mechanics or OS Design, each of which required 20-30 hours/week by itself.
I went to a decent state school, but I averaged more than 40 hours a week on classes and class work. Most of my classes were computer science, math and physics. I wanted to do well in things that were hard, so it was hard.
But I do agree with your main point: it's not lack of intelligence that prevents people from getting through certain majors. It's mostly a lack of motivation and work ethic.