Military Motivation and Frontier Maintenance
acoup.blog
acoup.blog
There's some description at [1]. At peak, it took a million soldiers to defend the wall. That's huge. China today has a military only about twice that size, and a far bigger population than in the days when the Wall mattered. Staffing the wall was using up a huge amount of manpower. That article, by an American, says the soldiers spent most of their time farming near the wall. So they were what the original posting calls "military settlers".
How was that huge army kept from taking over the country?
[1] https://www.china-mike.com/china-tourist-attractions/great-w...
What many people now see as the Great Wall of China was built by the Ming dynasty in the late 1400s and lasted at most 200 years before the Ming dynasty fell (they were still constructing it when the Ming dynasty fell, and the subsequent Qing dynasty declined to continue building it).
Before then, the walled fortifications were generally more sporadic, more temporary, and definitely more lightly manned. It would have required much fewer men to defend it--probably looking at say 20k for the Qin or Han era walls--and the Chinese state was, well, a state during much of this time period (by Weber's definition, that it has a monopoly on the legitimate use of force), unlike most of Medieval Europe.
Even then, the Chinese state failed several times over the course of two millennia, and a few of those times were quite literally people manning faraway places going "why are we doing this?" and sacking the capital.
The author channels a lot of clash of civilisation, which I am very fond of.
Anyway, I think I was mostly downvoted for expressing a negative idea than for the spelling error. He does contrast against Game of Thrones quite a bit, though, which I really appreciate. Game of Thrones has a lot of sort of unpleasant aspects that GRRM tries to pass off as realism; and while the past was full of unpleasantness, the voice that says “actually this is a bit over the top and unrealistically grim” is always appreciated.
Maybe that would have been a more well received version of my post… oh well.