They won't be the closest. If there are 5 people, 4 write 10 and 1 writes 510 then the average is 550/5 or 110. Which is much closer to 10 than it is to 510.
right, I see how I missed that. but the silver lining is that one outlier would have made everyone else seem very close to the final answer (% wise). this means if the professor is grading on a curve the whole class gets a 'C' except the outlier. sort of like 'Jesus died for your sins' ;-)