Black hole in orbit around planet could be sign of advanced civilization
phys.org
phys.org
It cites a post in a journal that is "OPEN ACCESS Research Notes of the AAS is a non-peer reviewed, indexed and secure record of works in progress, comments and clarifications, null results, or timely reports of observations in astronomy and astrophysics." ... So a blog?
Does our understanding of science allow for this? At a surface level, it seems like it does. Is it likely? Who knows.
The comments on this article are kind of weird. Dr. Loeb is one of the handful of scientists where SETI-style research is their bread and butter - it's not like we're throwing thousands of our best and brightest at this research at the expense of something more practical. Do you just fundamentally disagree with the idea of scientists doing research and theorizing potential technosignatures?
Calling this a blog is also quite dismissive - it's not like this is some random dude who wrote some random stuff and got picked up. It's a work in progress from one of the most knowledgeable scientists in this field.
I guess my disdain for this field's scientific rigor shines through. When hypotheses aren't testable...
> Calling this a blog is also quite dismissive - it's not like this is some random dude who wrote some random stuff and got picked up. It's a work in progress from one of the most knowledgeable scientists in this field.
That is a fair point!
Your expectation is infeasible. Setting that expectation is irresponsible.
I'm not finding any good answers to where the Eddington limit is but what I am finding has a few more zeroes than this and simply doesn't glow brightly enough to be useful.
Not to mention that it's going to be surrounded by an energetic particle cloud.
I'm messing with you. Mostly. But you have to assume, as the premise, that these sort of things can be solved. Notably, you have to sling a lot of matter at it, so you may as well sling a lot so you can miss some. And maybe the leftover matter getting heated up by radiation/particle cloud is part of your energy recovery mechanism?
Alien life in the universe is extremely likely. That does not mean however that every odd phenomenon is evidence of that alien life. It's unlikely (possible but unlikely) some alien civilization has a pet black hole in orbit of their planet. Just a random comet getting grabbed by its gravity could generate dangerous x-ray bursts for the planet's inhabitants. Jumping to the conclusion of "it's aliens!" is unscientific and really a bit tiring.
Though, a black hole of the size we're talking about is in and of itself potentially evidence of aliens - as noted in the article, they would evaporate within a year and a half without a constant influx of mass. Most places where you would find a black hole that is accreting matter is going to be a place where there is enough matter for it to become significantly larger, and once it's away from places rich with matter, space is emptying enough there's basically no chance it's having that much fall in.
It kinda seems your jumping to conclusions, "sign" is not the same thing as "evidence". Sign is basically increasing the perceived likelihood, but it may mean an increase from e. g. 0.000001% (baseline) to e. g. 0.001%.
Add some other signs like presence of water, radio activity etc. (each of which alone is no proof of aliens) and you can get interesting candidates.
"Black hole in orbit around planet could be a sign that physics in that section of the universe is very similar or even identical to ours"