I’m not saying it’s right, but what would the law look like making it illegal and what would the impact be positive and negative?
I’m not saying it’s right, but what would the law look like making it illegal and what would the impact be positive and negative?
The fact that this question even needs to be asked at all shows just how dire the state of consumer rights in tech is.
If there's a difference in this context, please clarify.
I was hoping for a discussion about exactly what I said. The basis for such a law and its impacts.
I guess the shouldn't have used the word "full" but that's pretty picky.
It looks like a pretty reasonable argument to me. They didn't discuss the basis but "consumer protection" seems to me to be sufficient basis. For impacts, I'm not sure what you're looking for; without being an expert it's hard to go beyond "companies stop doing that". But either way, replies don't have to answer every question you asked.
How about "you can't sell a tool that actively works against the interests of the customer"?
I'm sure some more targeted path could be taken. Like outlawing selling non-OSS. That sure would be nice...
One could argue that using copyright and eulas to bypass first sale is a misuse of copyright (the standard penalty for that is “you lose your copyright”, which seems completely reasonable and proportional to me).
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Computer,_Inc._v._Fran....
> The district court found in favor of Franklin. However, Apple appealed the ruling to the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit which, in a separate case decided three days after Franklin won at the lower level, had determined that both a program existing only in a written form unreadable to humans (e.g. object code) and one embedded on a ROM were protected by copyright. (See Williams Elec., Inc., v. Artic Int'l, Inc., 685 F.2d 870 (1982)). The Court of Appeals overturned the district court's ruling in Franklin by applying its holdings in Williams and going further to hold that operating systems were also copyrightable.
Yes, that was the premise of the complaint.
> Citation
I don't see anything here that resembles first sale, just a ruling that copyright applies to compiled code. The concept of first sale doctrine is that despite the presence of the seller's ip the seller loses control over most uses. Nobody is arguing against the existence of the copyright.