I'm sure some states without REAL ID already make it hard to get a license. That wasn't my experience though. Missouri and Nebraska were more like, "oh, you've got a letter from your neighbor vouching that you're really Rusty Shackleford? Here you go, Mr. Shackleford!"
I think states and the feds have a legitimate non-nefarious interest in proving a person's identity under the appropriate circumstances.
The letter from your neighbor is surprisingly reliable. Certainly more reliable that a record of birth from Texas.
Birth certificates in general are pretty awful. IIRC there are like 12,000 known entities that issue them. Big states have required central registration for decades. For example, in New York the local municipality issues the birth certificate, but files a copy with the NYS (or NYC) Department of Health. Some smaller states left it to the town clerk in some tiny village. (Or did until relatively recently)
There are many many corner cases with these sorts of records. Normie middle class people born in the US with two parents have very neat chains of custody of their records. There are millions who have very messy backgrounds or who don’t have their DOB or name officially recorded at all.
Thats why voter ID laws are awful. You don’t have a fundamental right to an ID or obligation to have one, but you do have a right to vote. Putting friction in front of that is a means to disenfranchise people, it’s a form of poll tax.
I totally agree about voter ID laws. I'm sympathetic to at least the claimed reasons for wanting them, but in practice there's statistically insignificant amounts of provably invalid voting. It's not worth disenfranchising millions of legitimate voters to stop the handful of frauds.
The reactionaries are worried about the mark of the beast nonsense. When they cared about civil liberties beyond firearms, that would come up too. The left wingers are worried about disenfranchising the poor and elderly.
Thats one of the reasons why the ID landscape is and has been so crazy - there was opposition to central birth records 100 years ago.
Texas isn’t alone - in point it out because a few years ago a few thousand people, including serving military officers, were effectively stripped of citizenship. They were likely born in Mexico and issued a birth certificate on a fraudulent basis as an infant.
I mean, if your position is that state IDs shouldn't really mean much, that's fine. But say that. But without REAL ID we'd require at least passport cards for air travel and a lot of other federal-related purposes. Which is fine I guess but probably a more expensive and heavyweight process than it needs to be.
I don't know if the immigration status checks are tracked, but the social security number checks are, as part of the check is to verify no cross-state usage of the same number for different identities.
You realize that the 9/11 hijackers (the event that kicked off this stuff) were traveling with valid identification.
The Feds are trying to mandate it, hence the push.
The issue with it is that many people, especially the elderly, poor people, and kids in complex non-custodial families have a hard time getting their physical social security card. Replacement of that document is a major pain in the ass.
It’s a big waste of money, tied to even bigger wastes of money like voter id.