> One District Court judge ruled against a similar suit:
https://reason.com/volokh/2024/08/26/judge-preliminarily-blo...
Thanks for the link. The lawsuit looks slightly different to me. They blocked a CID request where they got a request for a bunch of data about their operations. The requester did not manage to make a good case as to why that request had merit and therefore should not get counted as abusive.
The X lawsuit directly alleges that media matters tried to cause financial harm. It looks like X simply made a better argument as to why they had a good case against Media Matters.
> As far as I know, Media Matters never represented that n% of major advertisers' ads were shown next to racist content, just that some ads were, and that seems undisputed.
I had understood it like this as well. Musk alleges that they got the example through contrived means and that they did it purely to hurt X financially.
I do not think he will win but I do think the case merits examination.