During the Cold War era there was kind of an uneasy alliance between actual-libertarians and conservatives against authoritarian leftism and Marxism. National conservatism and MAGA are kind of an explicit rebuke of that alliance. The model is now more like Orban's Hungary: big government in service of right-wing goals.
This shift really started during the Bush II era. I remember seeing the writing on the wall back then that if the right couldn't win its culture war democratically it would abandon democracy, and if freedom meant too many people doing things they didn't like they would abandon freedom.
Actual-libertarians are kind of orphaned right now and may become a wing of the Democratic Party... at least the ones who aren't antivax conspiritainment kooks. Those will probably remain permanently orphaned or eventually follow the libertarian-to-alt-right pipeline and become fascists.
This is a weird time for small government pro-individual-liberty libertarians. On one hand many things that such people have fought for like drug decriminalization and LGBTQ+ rights are winning, at least in many US states. On the other hand the movement itself is on the ropes being pounded from both the authoritarian left and the authoritarian right, both of which have experienced surges in the last decade or so. Saying you are a 'liberal' in this sense in 2024 is deeply unpopular and will get you attacked from both sides.
I think it's anxiety over change. Any time you have a lot of change happening the instinctive human behavior is to grab hold of a big strong (usually) man to protect you. You're seeing this globally right now: Trump, Putin, Orban, Xinpeng, Maduro, etc.