It's difficult to argue that, for instance, training a model on all of Frank Miller's work then prompting it to generate comic art in Frank Miller's style then selling that is fair use.
It's difficult to argue that, for instance, training a model on all of Frank Miller's work then prompting it to generate comic art in Frank Miller's style then selling that is fair use.
And in my opinion (which is unfortunately more controversial than I think it should be) what LLMs do is far more akin to tracing than inspired creative expression. And I think intent is relevant here. Someone using an LLM to create a product in Frank Miller's style, trained on Frank Miller's work, isn't merely trying to create something inspired by his style, so much as create a Frank Miller product without having to pay Frank Miller.
"trouble" of what nature? You'd probably face more social consequences than legal.
Even if you want to argue that fair use didn't apply to Google, it clearly applies far less to what AI is used for.
It's _copy_right. If reproducing verbatim snippets was "transformative" enough to fall under fair use, I don't see why producing whole new books would not count as "transformative" enough. Copyright is a regime to grant monopoly over a specific work, it's not a regime to prevent competition from others in general.
If Google was selling brand new books created only by taking snippets from other books, that would also fall under fair use?