I like the relative mobility in the Indian system since anyone can swot to the test, but clearly the US system is much more enjoyable for a wider variety of students and they have a wider range of skills.
I think I'd like for my children to have a composite of the two. I dislike neverending homework and love tests because spiky activity allows for lots of self-directed exploration and the tests allow for evaluation. Though it's like that this is because I, personally, am quite capable with tests: I operate very well under time pressure and have an exceptional memory.