Internet Archive has it: https://archive.org/details/b28114450
Also look into "mouth taping".
Internet Archive has it: https://archive.org/details/b28114450
Also look into "mouth taping".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Catlin#Observations_on_...
I mouthtape and I got a full beard! Just use the 3M medical tape from Walgreens.
I don't do it every night, but I do it on occasion. Used to do it more. I find it's helped me just sleep mouth closed as normal now.
I have a beard and use GrifGrips sports tape to mouth tape. I've found the level of adhesiveness to be a perfect balance of strength and removability. Not the cheapest, but quality stuff.
This has all the hallmarks of quackery.
Why do you think how to live healthy is a modern invention? Don't you think people had to figure that out ages ago, or else we wouldn't be here?
Your argument is just a mix of the appeal to nature fallacy and noble savage trope that people use to justify all sorts of medical treatments with no proven benefits.
The Romans had great health. Proof: here we are thousands of years later alive and using their letters.
Not really, no. They had many ideas about health that we know are false now. And we still don't know a lot. Generally people died really young in those days.
But these things don't really matter for the population continuity if people get sick after they get kids, and they used to have them really early in those days (and many). They just didn't usually live until their 90s.
And of course knowing how to live healthy and actually doing it are different things too. It's something we really struggle with as a society and me too.
But I did “look into ‘mouth taping’” as you suggested, and I’ll bet half the page titles were “Mouth-taping: is it safe?” or “…does it work?” At what point does Betteridge’s Law of Headlines[0] kick in?
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines
Have you read the book? Do you think I'd be recommending something that didn't have a very strong dataset backing it?
> At what point does Betteridge’s Law of Headlines[0] kick in?
Nothing is easier to manipulate than digital symbols. Thus, when talking about patterns one finds in digital symbols, one much be very very careful to build a trusthworthy dataset. Do you have a trusthworthy dataset on Betterridge's headlines?
— Buster Baxter (written by Matt Steinglass, 2005)
People make stuff up, especially online. If you expect others to believe you about your "very strong dataset", you should provide that very strong dataset (complete with provenance).
"During my Ethnographic labours amongst those wild people I have visited 150 Tribes, containing more than two millions of souls ; and therefore have had, in all probability, more extensive opportunities than any other man living, of examining their sanitary system ;"
This author is one of the good 19th-century anthropologists (as judged by his scathing criticism of the institutions of 19th-century anthropology), but he's still a 19th-century anthropologist. The books' framing device is the idea that “the Tribes of North and South America” (including Sioux! with horses!!) lived in a “primitive condition”: while his observations are careful, and believable, his conclusions are incredible leaps of logic.
I can confidently assert that mouth-breathing does not deform the spine.
> That's what you call a "very strong dataset"‽
Yes!!!
Then, he had visited England which did not practice closed mouths and had poor health and poor teeth.
That's strong advice.
Then, he visited England which did speak English (as a primary language) and had poor health and poor teeth.
Frankly, the conclusion is irrefutable.
A working model of nature >> a large symbolic dataset >> a large personal dataset >> anecdotes.
This is a bit of #1 and #3.
Sure, #2 would be great, but #1 (mouth breathing bad) seems highly likely given both studying anatomy and modeling the physics of breathe and also given his dataset #3.
I agree that mouth breathing is probably bad. I don't agree that it causes spinal deformation or smallpox. I really don't think taping the mouth shut is a safe treatment for sleep apnea.