Google would gladly have removed them and acted as a broker for anonymized targeting data, but it would have killed other players in the ad ecosystem and given them exclusive power as the distributer of chrome.
Google would gladly have removed them and acted as a broker for anonymized targeting data, but it would have killed other players in the ad ecosystem and given them exclusive power as the distributer of chrome.
That doesnt mean there isnt a case or anticompetitive practices aren’t occurring
Corporations are conduits, getting shareholders to multi trillion dollar valuations is worth it when the only consequences will just affect the shell of the corporation remaining
Are third party cookies a good thing?
(Context for anyone interested, also note citations 1 and 2) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_cookies
Theoretically yes, they are intended to hold some piece of state that is relevant to or derived from your usage and that's not bad by itself. Third-parties aren't always ads either, you might embed maps or AI or countless other things that can use this.
In practice, they have been abused for tracking very widely and they support all these other uses so much that we expanded this idea to include local storage, session storage, indexed storage etc.
An app like this is probably not ideal for outward facing sites but I have seen apps like this serve its purpose very well as an internal app and the simplicity allows it to have less tech overhead.
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/entra/identity-platform/v2...
You seem to have missed these important parts of the statement:
> This app can implement super simple auth...
> ...the simplicity allows it to have less tech overhead.
OAuth is not simple, and for something entirely internal, simple is fine.
Safari disables third party cookies, but I didn't call them independent because they have their own ad ecosystem (so of course they want to nerf web ads).
Third-party cookies, as a naive identifier on their own, are comparatively straightforward and controllable. It's all the other tricks around them that make it worrisome.