Hacker News Reader

Comment by alt227 | Hacker News Reader

> system slowdown

This is often touted as a downside for the registry, and indeed a whole ecosystem of apps have evolved around this concept to 'clean' the registry and 'speed it up'.

In my experience of 35 years of using windows, I have never noticed a bloated registry slowing down a computer. I have also never noticed a speed up of the system by removing some unused keys. The whole point of addresses and key pairs is that individual bits of data can be written or read without loading the whole hive.

I wonder where this idea of a bloated slow registry came from?

View on HN

Since the registry is a database, I would expect adding and removing branches and leaves would create fragmentation that, in the age of spinning metal and memory pressure, could create performance issues. A file system is easily defragmenters with tools available in the operating system itself, but not the registry. I’m not even sure how much of it can be optimised (by doing garbage collection and defragmenting the underlying files) with the computer running.

If it makes use of indexes, changes will lead to the indexes themselves being fragmented, making performance even worse.

The registry was capable of being compacted, negating the need to defragment it. This was done via the standard Windows Backup utility provided OOTB.

As for performance, the registry was mapped in paged pool memory[0]; only sections in-use needed to be mapped. Other hives were volatile and never persisted to disk. When data is added to the registry, the paged pool expands to accommodate. Maximum registry size is based off of installed memory, up to a limit.

Registry subkeys are organized alphabetically in an internal list; searches are binary searches rather than using an index. Searches begin in the middle of the list and go up or down based upon the alphabetical value being searched for (so start at 50% -> up/down, split remaining list 50%, up/down -> repeat until found).

You can find more info in Chapter 4 of Windows Internals 4th Edition.

Needless to say, none of the concerns you presented were valid back in the dark days.

[0] https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/sysinfo/regi...

Anecdotally I've experienced several PC's that became slow/unstable/unusable after a number of years. I can't scientifically prove it was due to the registry (other than a couple that had specific corruption).

But after I started using Total Uninstall religiously, from day 1 of a PC's life, my desktops have lasted indefinitely - going on 15 years for the latest one (yes, really). Hardware was of course upgraded along the way, making old driver removal paramount (which TU is very helpful with).

Analyzing it's logs after a software installation has also been helpful to spot and surgically remove unwanted keys like autostarts, Explorer addins, etc.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com