sighThis is silly, and you probably think you are being smart.
That's not what's being argued. Read the parent comment, and there is an expectation that it's your data and you have the right to decide what to do with it, and that you essentially should be able to dictate to other companies how they have to share it.
I call bullshit.
> What about the posts I put on Craigslist in the future?
What about them? T&C. It's your data. You are choosing to give it to Craigslist.
> The ratings I give to Netflix?
What about them? Those are your rating? You are choosing to give it to Netflix so Netflix can give you better recommendations.
> Am I somehow mystically bound to never ask for more in return for the data I provide them?
That was never suggested. Nor is it what is happening here. People are acting self-entitled, demanding that their data, which they given to other companies, somehow is still theres by some non-existent right.
> Of course we can ask to change the terms. It's a business transaction.
Which has nothing to do with what's being discussed here.
Here, let me help explain: if you sign up and agree to use a site, and provide it with data, then the business relationship already exists. If you suddenly want more, you need to renegotiate. But that doesn't mean the company should be required to hand over that data (which is what many are suggesting) that they own (and just because it's about you, or you provided it, doesn't mean it's yours to control).
So yeah, you can ask them to change the terms. And when they don't, you stop using the service.
I swear, this is like reading a bunch of posts my self-entitled, egotistical nobodies who, in all truth, never really cared about their data in the first place.
After all, if you did, this wouldn't be a problem for you.