No, they don't. There are enough mechanisms in the tax code that many of the ultra wealthy pay nothing close to this, or anything at all. Buffet has famously complained about this.
No, they don't. There are enough mechanisms in the tax code that many of the ultra wealthy pay nothing close to this, or anything at all. Buffet has famously complained about this.
If you include FICA, it's more like the top 1% of income people pay ~30% of total tax (somewhere around there).
The bottom 50% of Americans own less than 3% of all wealth.
I really think that these figures need to start taking into account disposable income, so we can see just how fucking evil this situation really is. There's over 8 million hungry kids in the wealthiest country on the planet. Half a million families file for bankruptcy every year due to medical debt. Etc.
And people are arguing in all seriousness that we need to tax corporations and the wealthy even less, quoting Thatcher and cherry-picking misleading stats. Ugh.
So if I understood you correctly, yes, the rich pay a higher percentage of taxes if you ignore FICA, because the poor and middle class pay a much higher percentage of FICA.
Pedantically, only the social security part of FICA is capped. Medicare you still pay 1.45-2.35%, uncapped. But the 6.2% for social security is capped, and thus for the top end of the 1% ends up being a miniscule tax.
If you get rid of the social security cap, get rid of mortgage interest deduction, and add a wealth tax, that more or less solves the 2034 debt to <100% of GDP right there.
Also note that FICA is only on "earned income" (not interest, dividends, capital gains, rental income...), and is not subject to the standard deductions.
Of course the other way of looking at it is that fica ultimately just comes out of the pocket of the rich. If there were no payroll taxes, fica would just stay in the employers pockets. Employers are mostly the rich. Or may be it would get embezzled by the middle management due to increased principal agent problem without the payroll tax paper trail…
i.e. the top 1% of tax filers by income paid nearly 50% of all taxes collected.
This is accurate per the latest statistics released by the IRS, for tax year 2021; the top 1% of returns paid 45.78% of all taxes collected.
https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-individual-stat...
https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/federal/latest-federal-in...
It's funny. If you had 100 people in a room, there's one guy paying for about 45 people. And the next 4 people are paying for about 5 people each (20 total). And the lowest paid 50 people combined are paying for about 2 people total.
I think we should just not have the bottom half of income earners in the US pay any taxes. It wouldn't change the numbers much, and then it would be one less thing for them to complain about.
However, I don't expect anyone to put down their torches and pitch forks any time soon. It's too easy to use this to get people spun up, even above average educated people as in this forum.
Where does the vast, vast majority of the value of their work go? It goes to the asset class - the top 1 or 2 people.
And you call the top guy generous because he pays ~40% tax on the money the bottom 90% made for him.
Even as he buys politicians, runs monopolies, subsidizes fossil fuel, and strip mines the planet for even more.
Don't make out like the 50% of people making 2 or 3% of income are just ungrateful, or bad at math. The insane level of inequality in America is literally an existential threat to humanity.