In an argument, you need to show the link between cause and effect, a chain of reasoning.
In an argument, you need to show the link between cause and effect, a chain of reasoning.
The reply is where both of these begin: illustration as a metaphor for metaphor (how meta!), and persuading the reader to take on a belief.
You made an assumption that I don't know how an argument goes and/or that I don't know how to use an analogue/metaphor, and you attacked me saying people don't accept analogues/metaphors.
This is about the same fallacy people perform when they don't accept analogues/metaphors or attack them instead. They claim it doesn't relate or illustrate, when infact they just fail to understand.
So yeah, you ran into the same issue.
E: And yes you are another user account, but since you defend the OP I assume you also hold the same view she does.
Presents that I would use an analogue/metaphor as an argument and/or that I don't know what they are or how to use them, which is an attack on my integrity/character/skills/etc.
By not accepting I meant they might say "what does that have to do with this?", "that's not related" or "that has nothing to do with this".
Ie. they completely skip over and don't accept the fact that it's an analogue and dismiss it or attack the analogue itself after.
I'm able to defend the other user from nonsense regardless of whether I share their view (though I do, most likely).
The reply to my post has the same issue, though yes in a wider adaptation. Not accepting a logically sound situation is the same as dismissing an analogue just because it's an analogue ("analogues are not arguments therefore not relevant"), and then presenting that I don't know how to use an analogue is about the same as attacking the analogue.
If there's nonsense it's from you.
The meaning of language, English anyhow, does tend to be however it gets commonly interpreted. I think it's helpful to advocate for communication that achieves successful interpretation over that which doesn't, even if that which doesn't work ought to work. Many things are noble pursuits even if against the grain, but using language in unsuccessful ways isn't one of them due to its nature which favors agreeance of usage.