Every book removed/withheld should be replaced by a volume explaining why it was withheld, in terms a child can understand. Some of these bans wouldn't have happened because even children could've seen how full of shit some adults are.
Every book removed/withheld should be replaced by a volume explaining why it was withheld, in terms a child can understand. Some of these bans wouldn't have happened because even children could've seen how full of shit some adults are.
You are aware that this already happens without bans, right?
The ultimate board of censors is the school and library staff that decides on your behalf what kind of books you and your kids should be exposed to.
It's not like the school library is some sort of the Great Library of Alexandria and the censors came to take out the "good stuff".
What happens is that the library staff is in position to censor and proselytize their ideologies and weird secular religions. These bans really are aimed at library staff than restricting childrens access to read whatever they want.
I'm used to most libraries being part of a national system of libraries, which will get you volumes shipped from another one if they don't have it there.
Local curation doesn't mean much since your main interface to those libraries nowadays is a digital one that has pretty much any physical media with an ISBN in it, from where you can request non-locally-available media.
Maybe the states operate differently and (school) libraries are more independent. Most schools here don't have their own library at all and instead rely on the nearest public one...
I highly doubt school libraries function any differently. Every year you receive a magazine with books who received prizes/recommendations, you move older books that aren't read to the reserve and command new ones. In my country, you especially have the 'highschooler prize' (not sure how to translate it), which is voted upon by students from 50 different highschool accross the country, and the winners are always recommended by the magazine.
My advice would be, rather than preventing librarians to do their job, maybe write better books? Prevent new commands rather than remove already existing books? Because putting 'Go Tell It on the Mountain' on the shelves isn't ideology, just good taste. Removing it is.
What really grind my gear is that I would bet censors don't read or review books. Book reviewing was a staple of my curriculum from 11 to 16, so I imagine it isn't hard. Censors should have to write at least a book review a year, graded (not to prevent them to censor, just publish the grade so we could see their reading level).
Changing that would require to put educated people in schools ... and that would require competing with senior-level jobs in private companies which at this point would be a doubling or tripling or even more of teacher pay in quite a few places.
Most library boards are very happy to order any book that is requested by multiple students. My daughter's high school library contains a lot of manga that would never have been ordered by any "ultimate board of censors".
Do these concerned parents (censors) want to take off Harry Poters and The Hobbit and similar in demand youth literature?
Doesn't look like it at all.
As far as I can tell, kids aren't interested in most of the weird shit what's getting restricted from the school library. The only people that are concerned about the books in question being restricted in public schools are ideologues that want to peddle their weirdo stuff to kids.
Also, I know several parents who would love to see Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings banned because they say they are about the Occult and demons and Anti-Christian and so on. Many are vocal about it at school board meetings. I don’t think librarians should give in to these bullies, either.
I'm sure there are. But was Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings restricted? Or literature kids want to read? No?
Then you don't have an argument.
If the books that were restricted are of no interest to kids, nor does their parents want their kids exposed to it by ideologically driven librarians or teachers, I don't see any issue in it whatsoever.
Keep in mind that school libraries can allow books about World War 2 without promoting (or peddling) war.
Also, Harry Potter constantly tops lists of most-banned books in libraries.
>Also, Harry Potter constantly tops lists of most-banned books in libraries.
Well, then that is clearly bad.
The article does clearly communicate and wear it's convictions on it's sleave about what it is concerned about, and I see no mention of Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings there.
I think the people who spend the most time in school libraries must be the Book Banners, desperately looking high and low for something to be outraged about.
The only weird ideology youve cited so far is “human sexuality” which is neither weird nor an ideology.
Children should not be exposed to sexual material at an early developmental age. That's sexual child abuse.
In the US you mean? This is a thing to ban books in libraries, especially ones that sell well?