This also involves trust. The party doing aggregation has access to non-aggregated information and is able to sell it. As far as I understand, currently this party is ISRG, which has reasonably good reputation and probably won’t sell it. I don’t trust Mozilla to not silently add other aggregation providers though, as they did with this option itself. I’m also not sure that this data doesn’t pass through Mozilla servers, and I very much don’t trust Mozilla with it.
To summarize my thoughts,
1. There’s no evidence that “PPA” improves privacy in any way;
2. You have to trust centralized third parties doing the aggregation, and the full set of parties you need to trust is not completely clear;
3. The only party who obviously benefits from “PPA” is advertisers, which tracks with the fact that the protocol was designed with heavy involvement from Facebook: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KpdSKD8-Rn0bWPTu4UtK54ks...;
4. So it’s at best neutral for users and at worst is actively detrimental.