I don't really see how that example is "giv[ing] things back." That stone is still the property of the British government and kept continuously on British territory.
But even with 1707 you’re talking 30% of the age of the USA again.
Great Britain the name of the island both are located upon. England and Scotland will always be a part of Britain, because that's a geographical area, not a political one.
Not necessarily: they could dig a big canal across the island along the border.