Oh yeah, we went through that 2000 years ago and the winner was pi. I haven't seen any compelling reason to switch yet. (Says the guy who uses "j" for the imaginary constant. :P)
Oh yeah, we went through that 2000 years ago and the winner was pi. I haven't seen any compelling reason to switch yet. (Says the guy who uses "j" for the imaginary constant. :P)
The Pi Manifesto has a few examples of pi beating tau (statistics, polygons, and complex numbers mainly), while also pointing out how silly and biased some of the tau examples are. However, the argument isn't very convincing from either side.
And as to your second question, I have no idea. I just know the idea has been settled for a long time now and I think this whole debate is needlessly distracting. Not that it isn't fun to watch or think about, but it confuses people who are just trying to learn and use math.
Their argument about trigonometric functions is completely wrong and obviously so. Trigonometric functions work with angles and it's already shown (and pimanifesto readily admits) that tau shines there.
Their argument about Euler's identity is as inane as the tauists' is.
They don't understand quadratic forms.
I'm guessing this site is sarcastic.
τché!
I've also seen arguments that it's better when dealing with triangles (all angles in a triangle add up to pi radians). I don't think I buy that one, since everyone uses degrees for that anyway.
I always thought Tau was better because it was easier to understand when teaching it. For using it, it doesn't much matter.
But when you are a kid learning about it, having a clear picture of why specifically that number is very important, and Tau is much more obvious.
This argument is addressed explicitly in the section "What is really going on here?":
I haven't heard of tau being considered pre-2001, though it must have happened here and there (I had the same idea independently, for example).
Not the same now, of course, with shows like Numb3rs and Big Bang Theory, and a greater public awareness of the importance of numeracy.
Really? It's just two constants that are both easy to remember and trivial to convert between.
I don't have a horse in this race. I don't mind having two distinct constants to deal with.
#define ONE 1 #define TWO 2 #define THREE 3 ... etc.
Then use the words in place of integers wherever you need them. Hell, mix and match. And tell me if you are just as productive as you would be sticking with the regular integers you know and love.
Then we'll go back in a couple weeks, and look at the same code again. Mine's wordy. Yours is cryptic, and requires looking up the use of everything.
goes online to see if he can find answer to question before asking... Nope, sorry.