How to Tax the Rich: Piketty
lemonde.fr
lemonde.fr
But I dream of a world where the US and EU agree to both introduce a wealth tax. Unfortunately I think the democracies of the world will rather crumble under unsustainable wealth disparancy than do something like that:-/
Consumption taxes are paid by the very wealthy, and are very difficult to avoid
They are regressive, but that can be fixed by universal citizens' dividends.
Take from the rich and give to everybody
The rest of your argument is that governments are bad and that money spent there is always better spent by a billionaire. Idk what kind of dysfunctional society made you think this, and I definitely agree that there are such dysfunctional societies out there, but for functioning ones this is clearly wrong.
Government invests in stuff like national defence, law system, education and health care. These are clearly beneficial and highly profitable things, they are in fact the stage on which the billionaires build their wealth. And if the billionaires don't help pay for it, the middle class must.
I never said money is always better spent by billionaires, I made the distinction I reiterated and expanded on above and said government has a lifecycle so where in the lifecycle a government is determines how likely it is to spend money better than a billionaire (or better than any individual for that matter), but again that comparison is individual because there are differences among individuals and governments and the devil is in the details. I have the most experience with the USA and Canada and I would say both of those are corrupt and wasteful enough to give serious pause to any desire to send them any additional money but they are both still productive enough that the inefficiency and waste isn't necessarily obvious to everyone yet (it's probably coming, wait a decade or two and if you don't see a mass downsizing of the federal labor force or other large reduction in spending with a smaller reduction in services to stave off the obviousness it will likely be obvious to all by then.)
Certainly they do those things, how they do those things determines whether the government is efficient or wasteful. Whether they are beneficial or highly profitable is up for debate because none of the words you mentioned are actual things, they are amalgamations of good and bad things and the ratio matters a lot. I'm a fan of progressive income taxes as I like paying more if I get more benefit and I certainly benefit from effectively provided healthcare, roads, education because my workforce gets more productive and my customers get richer and more able to buy stuff. This isn't the issue here, the issue here is understanding how likely more money to government will benefit society or benefit politicians and harm society and understanding that most of the problem with billionaires isn't a billionaire problem, it's an antitrust problem, for which we have a legislated solution that we need to grow up and start using again (break up the large company exercising market power causing deadweight loss, regulate business practice to outlaw stupid anticompetitive crap like most of what makes up a seller contract with amazon these days).
The concern is also that piketty fundamentally misunderstands the effect of a wealth tax on capital markets. they will be forced to sell stock/companies to pay it and that will crush the financial market. Of the group of billionaires that are actually doing a good job pushing the production possibilities frontier out, it is also actively harmful because it diminishes their control of their companies and harms company financing capability. The system shock of somthing like a 10 or 20% wealth tax will cause a lot of deadweight loss that Piketty does not appreciate while doing nothing more than funneling money into questionable governments. If one is going to disrupt the financial market like that one should at least be doing it mitigating market power by, for example, breaking up the obvious oligopolies that infest our business environment.
Idea is to keep the billionaires in control of the (unspent) assets. Government over time might become largely funded by this means greatly reducing the need for middle class taxation.
Everytime I see a discussion of taxing the rich, we have some weird pseudo tax raise for poor and middle-class instead by defining the rich as some super minimum wage and putting the maximum squeen on anyone above poverty to lower middle class.
"Strong" economists don't need to fudge their data.
The only real move to tax the wealthy is to end trusts... everywhere. Everything else spills over onto the middle class, and those who aren't mobile enough to get out of the way. But the middle class doesn't use trusts.
You can try to regulate loans against securities, but you're right back to putting "regular folk" in the cross-hairs. This talk of taxing potential gains would create a mechanism through which governments could absolutely ruin ordinary individuals while never touching the purported targets.
The wealth increases he refers to here are largely calculated by marking public market stock prices to a recent trading price. That wealth is not real: it is in potentia and predicated at least in part on the markets beliefs about who will be selling and how much. Seizing or accepting tax payments by forcing a sale of a large amount of stock is going to generate huge losses as stock prices adjust : I don’t understand how you can see this as anything but at best wealth transfer. The wealth being transferred is out of billionaire pockets, and also out of every single shareholders pockets , including pension funds, retirees: ..
“Meh” he says, just sell it to existing employees. At what price? It’s just extremely lazy thinking from a very intelligent man.
And who will buy? Other billionaires yes, but they will pay the state, so the end result is moving of wealth from the billionaires to the state.
And regarding your 'state ownership' tabu, Scandinavia says hi;-) But that's a different discussion, for this tax I am fine with the state continuously selling it.
In contrast the US economy and legal system fully bake the neoliberal economic viewpoint into our institutions: we are a country that outsources almost everything including everything financial to the private sector.
To me it’s just extremely unlikely that a system like that would work. Sadly because if my social security payments over the years had gone to temasek I would have done quite well..
That said, this article is pretty flimsy on any realistic way to deal with disgusting levels of wealth accumulation and inequality.