Even after it was called out, and after looking at it, it still looks like a low res planet crescent or other attempts to make animated logo graphics. Why are we sure that wasn't the intent?
I think the "perfectionist" is social and Hollywood (and tabliod/lawsuit) cover for "this person abuses people on set." In Kubrick's case it certainly was, famously with Duvall in the Shining, but rumored with other talent too.