Consumers, especially lower-income ones, mostly look at the sticker price. Paying upfront and getting a discount later is the opposite of what they want and carriers know this.
A. Pay money upfront and get a discount every month.
B. Pay nothing upfront but the service is full price. (This is what I see on the T-Mobile site.)
My point is that many people prefer B even if the total cost is higher.
Not trying to move goal posts though. You’re right about that one and it’s pretty shitty.