Laptop CPUs run hot, there isn't a lot of room for airflow or cooling. Hardware degrades with time/heat/cycles, so if it was used hard, it might be close to the end of its usable life.
This has been a problem for me pretty much every time I've recycled an old laptop. The CPU/mobi/ram still works fine but the cooling screen battery and case are often going after a few years in and out of the backpack.
I'd love to recycle them myself, suppose I could ask the folks at Re:PC next time I do a drop off
I personally don't like external Docks at all, i prefer displays with integrated usb-c pd docks.
It's a bit like buying a used car - if you are not an expert, it's risky, but avoiding obvious red flags 70% of the time you're not getting ripped of and you save a lot of money.