Can you name a single species whose speciation-by-random-mutation we have witnessed? Have I missed the Down-syndrome one (or any analogous known gene mutation) which has been continuously procreating all this time?
Besides the fact that Down-syndrome is a terrible example since Down-syndrome-parents would not necessarily produce offspring with the same genetic disorder, hence no speciation-by-random-mutation.
I thought people learn this stuff in HS...
Since evolution moves slowly there are two ways to see it in action: either you experiment with a species that reproduces very rapidly, or you look at fossil records. For the first type bacteria are usually used, but since bacteria don't have sexual reproduction a naysayer could always cast doubt on whether a new species has truly been created (are any two individual bacteria really the same species? Who can tell, short of verifying base-by-base equality of their DNA), so it won't convince someone who is determined to doubt evolution. For the fossil records we have literal mountains of evidence where the development of existing and extinct species can be observed. But I imagine you won't count that as "witnessing" it happening.
I feel like many people who doubt evolution use a standard of evidence that they don't use for any other scientific theory, and probably not for any other area in their life either. Other people have mentioned it already: plate tectonics, almost all of astronomy... we could extend it to history too. Did you witness the founding of the United States? If documented history count as proof of stuff like founding of the US, the civil war, and the first world war, then why don't fossils count as proof of evolution?
This why your lion + tiger is not some special case, it trivially fails the definition: Their offspring are sterile.
Now ring species as you describe have not been shown to exist. Let me refer you as well to this brilliant article by an evolutionist explaining that: https://whyevolutionistrue.com/2014/07/16/there-are-no-ring-...
In short, the suspected ring species were found to produce fertile offspring when interbreeding at the ring-closing point (!).
> The authors [...] found, contrary to previous information, that there are indeed some hybrids (fertile ones, since they backcross) produced where the ring closes at the top, so they aren’t really acting like full biological species.
So we cannot be certain that where the ring closes, inter-breeding is impossible, because it has been shown to occur. Further:
> In the end, the authors conclude [...]: there are no good examples of ring species in nature
---
It's not about "doubting" in a religious sense. As an intellectual and academic I simply reserve the right to challenge and poke holes as rigorously as I can into any theory presented to me. What I found is that speciation-by-random-mutation appears to fail my (admittedly difficult but nonetheless valid) challenge.
As for plate tectonics: Look, if I were to say the evidence in my eyes does not support the theory well enough, would that make me unscientific? Of course not! The best counter-example I just posted are ring species - scientists once had extreme confidence in their existence, only to be disappointed after new findings.
But in the interest of considering the topic from an intellectual and academic point of view, what is your proposed alternative explanation for the huge number of species we see today, apart from evolution and speciation?
There are just a few aspects about it that don't fully compute in my mind.
Take this for example, and bear with me for a moment:
The earth is 4.5b yrs old. Say 4b yrs ago life began. Just in the past 500m yrs, there were 5 major extinction events, with perhaps 80-90% of species going extinct each time on avg.
Homo erectus are said to emerge something shy of 2 mio yrs ago. Denisovans are much younger. Us and Denisovans are genetically one species (we could produce viable offspring). The same holds with denisovans and homo erectus
This means we could probably viably procreate with homo erecti from ~2 mio yrs ago.
So across 2 mio yrs, pretty much no speciation occurred with us (if at all ever, remember that is still conjecture if we're being strict).
Now remember the last major extinction was just ~65 mio yrs ago.
Yet there are what, 1-2 billion different species alive today?
I know there is parallelization involved as the model goes, but to me it seems there was still very little time for all that to happen given that a single speciation event takes millions of years.
I'm not saying evolution by speciation is false. I'm just saying perhaps it's insufficient.
---
All of that said, speciation - or even evolution and science in general (!) - is not at odds with my religious beliefs anyway, as long as we are being true to what's certain and what's conjecture.
We’d have to see them turn into organisms that were very different from their original form or even multi-cellular. That would be closer to what evolution as origin of life says. Instead, most (all?) stay what they are with minor adaptations.
We’ve also observed billions of other creatures over thousands of years that didn’t turn into new insects or animals. Evolution’s predictions on a macro-level have failed over a billion times for thousands of years.
On the fossil record, evolution predicted continuous streams of changes in all directions with piles of viable, intermediate forms. We don’t see that. We do see large jumps from one type to another happening after extinctions where there’s lower populations.
“use a standard of evidence that they don’t use for any other scientific theory”
That’s exactly what evolutionists do. These failures of the theory, both observational and historical, would have had it tossed long ago like most theories that fail that much. Instead, they keep making excuses for it or emphasizing again that it must be true.
That’s not science. That is like dogma driven by emotional or socio-political factors. Which also provably exist in institutions promoting it. So, it’s not science since it (a) is driven by non-scientific forces and (b) continues to fail the scientific method.
Let's take a look at the E. coli long term evolution experiment [1]! Here we see 12 initially identical populations of bacteria live through over 80k generations over a period of 36 years. During this time these isolated populations have undergone significant changes (such as becoming at least twice as large) that would surely qualify as "very different from their original form". One of the populations evolved the ability to aerobically grow on citrate. Not being able to do this is one of the defining qualities of E.coli, so it must surely qualify as becoming 'very different'.
> We’ve also observed billions of other creatures over thousands of years that didn’t turn into new insects or animals. Evolution’s predictions on a macro-level have failed over a billion times for thousands of years.
Speciation is usually a gradual process. There won't be a clear instant where yesterday there was one species and today it's suddenly two species. So in that regard there isn't a specific moment one could personally observe. And with the time between generations for animals being relatively long, we don't see much progress being made. What we do see around us is species in various stages of speciation. Here is a nice example of speciation starting for European birds [2] that is very recent.
Also I would argue that the E.coli experiment has shown speciation in a human lifetime.
> On the fossil record, evolution predicted continuous streams of changes in all directions with piles of viable, intermediate forms. We don’t see that. We do see large jumps from one type to another happening after extinctions where there’s lower populations.
Citation needed? We have lots of species living today that we can trace to shared ancestors, like how we can trace humans, chimps, and orangutans to a common ancestor. It's true that speciation happens much faster after an extinction, this makes sense because extinction events cause previously occupied ecological niches to get opened up. In a static environment the rate of change is low because most species will be in a local optimum. Everything we see appears to confirm evolution. If you think the fossil record disproves evolution you should consider if it merely disproves your understanding of evolution, which may be incorrect.
> That’s exactly what evolutionists do. These failures of the theory, both observational and historical, would have had it tossed long ago like most theories that fail that much. Instead, they keep making excuses for it or emphasizing again that it must be true.
You mean biologists? To call evolution a failed theory is absurd, it's one of the most successful theories science has produced. It's supported by the fossil record, by DNA research, by bacteria becoming resistant to antibiotics and gaining the ability to digest plastics. By vestigial organs. By the way that early fetal development for mammals all looks the same. And there are no counter examples. No species appearing out of nowhere without a historical ancestor. No species with completely incompatible biology to our own.
> That’s not science. That is like dogma driven by emotional or socio-political factors. Which also provably exist in institutions promoting it. So, it’s not science since it (a) is driven by non-scientific forces and (b) continues to fail the scientific method.
You are seeing a conspiracy where none exists. If you have a better theory than evolution I encourage you to publish, and in a decade or two we will all know you as a Nobel prize winner. Maybe share it with us here on HN, I for one would be delighted to have been one of the first to have read this new theory. I sure hope it doesn't rely on an invisible undetectable magic man steering everything.
Even if a theory is invented to supplant evolution, I guarantee it will include evolution. Just like General Relativity supplanted Newtonian Physics, turns out that they have pretty much the same results at the scales and speeds we usually find ourselves at. And just like the Earth being an oblate sphere instead of a perfect sphere. The basic idea of evolution is correct and any hypothetical future changes will be a refinement on what we already know, not a radically different thing.
1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._coli_long-term_evolution_... 2. https://evolution.berkeley.edu/evo-news/speciation-in-real-t...
Answers in Genesis has a nice takedown of that which links to a scientific publication about the citrate:
https://answersingenesis.org/genetics/mutations/richard-lens...
https://journals.asm.org/doi/pdf/10.1128/jb.180.16.4160-4165...
Once again, evolutionists report that an organism gained abilities it basically already had. There was no, new capabilities invented in the process. So, you might want to drop that one.
Re common ancestors
Most of what I saw in the past was them claiming that without proof. What they’d usually argue are similarities. Reuse of design, or iterations, happen in intelligent design done by human engineers. We reuse and tweak all kinds of stuff, esp mechanical and software. You don’t see people arguing an unguided, chance-based process must have produced the software because of the similarities in the code. Evolutionists take quite a leap.
Re failed theory w/ counter evidence
You said vestigial. That’s another thing I’m skeptical of. Scientists that don’t understand our bodies have said many things were useless in the past. Then, evolutionists said they were vestigial. Later, the appendix, the spleen, “junk DNA,” etc were proven to have important uses for people even though you can live without some of them.
Vestigial organs seem to be one of those things where evolutionists don’t know why something exists, make a statement of faith that it’s vestigial, and then use the faith-based statements (existence of vestigials) to back evolution theory itself. I don’t like that methodology since they’ve been wrong so many times.
Re fetal development
Same as before. There’s similarities. So, instead of designed with similarities (most likely), it must have been produced by unguided processes in hostile environments that endlessly added more capabilities starting with simple things they spontaneously formed from non-living material in a universe that accidentally formed life-preserving constants.
Yet, even those that believe this won’t rely on such processes to design anything because they don’t work. Even evolutionary algorithms and large, language models take lots of fine-tuning in environments hand-crafted for their execution. Why would I expect anything less of the more complex designs in the universe and of life? :)
Maybe you can stop with the disingenuous "evolutionists" and just call these people by their professions: biologists and geneticists.
Feeding on citrate under aerobic conditions is a new capability for the e. coli strain that the experiment started with. You can deny it all you want but that just shows the world that you're closing your eyes for what is right in front of you. If it was really such an easy ability to acquire you'd think that more than 1 of the 12 lines would have achieved it after 75k+ generations. But researching the strain that did develop the ability showed that it's a complex ability that required multiple mutations to acquire. It's not like the bacteria just activated a dormant gene that they already had.
But we can leave the e. coli behind and take another example: antibiotic resistance in bacteria and the ability to digest plastic of some bacteria. Many antibiotics (and also plastics in general) simply didn't exist before we invented them. And yet we see bacteria develop a resistance to antibiotics. And now that plastic is everywhere, some bacteria have evolved the ability to break it down. Clearly these are new and original abilities.
> Most of what I saw in the past was them claiming that without proof. What they’d usually argue are similarities. Reuse of design, or iterations, happen in intelligent design done by human engineers. We reuse and tweak all kinds of stuff, esp mechanical and software. You don’t see people arguing an unguided, chance-based process must have produced the software because of the similarities in the code. Evolutionists take quite a leap.
So you're suggesting evolution isn't true, it's actually an intelligent designer that is iterating on a design, resulting in... the development of species over time with a fossil record and existing species that looks exactly like an evolutionary tree, including physical traits, similarity in genetics... but it's definitely not evolution.
Speaking of reuse of design, in nature we actually see that something like (for example) the eye has evolved separately a bunch of times, with several variations. And miraculously these variations match the evolutionary trees for the species involved.
> You said vestigial. That’s another thing I’m skeptical of. Scientists that don’t understand our bodies have said many things were useless in the past. Then, evolutionists said they were vestigial. Later, the appendix, the spleen, “junk DNA,” etc were proven to have important uses for people even though you can live without some of them.
When I was talking about vestigial stuff I had the leg bones in some snakes in mind, that seem to VERY STRONGLY suggest that their ancestors may have had legs, and these legs have evolved away. Whales also have some bones left that again strongly suggest their ancestors once walked on land, but one could argue about whether these count as 'vestigial' since apparently some muscles are still connected to them. But regardless of vestigiality, they're clearly remains of legs.
> Vestigial organs seem to be one of those things where evolutionists don’t know why something exists, make a statement of faith that it’s vestigial, and then use the faith-based statements (existence of vestigials) to back evolution theory itself. I don’t like that methodology since they’ve been wrong so many times.
So you agree the scientific consensus updates as more information becomes available, as we see with vestigial organs losing their vestigial status when their use becomes known. And yet evolution has not been rejected by scientists. To me that sounds like the new information did not contradict evolution. Does it sound like a grand conspiracy to you?
> Same as before. There’s similarities. So, instead of designed with similarities (most likely), it must have been produced by unguided processes in hostile environments that endlessly added more capabilities starting with simple things they spontaneously formed from non-living material in a universe that accidentally formed life-preserving constants.
The origin of life is out of scope of evolution, so I don't see why you're bringing it up. Evolution would still be the leading theory about the historical and continued development of terrestrial life regardless of whether the first life arose from nonliving materials, was brought to earth by aliens, or was created by a deity from your pantheon of choice.
> Yet, even those that believe this won’t rely on such processes to design anything because they don’t work. Even evolutionary algorithms and large, language models take lots of fine-tuning in environments hand-crafted for their execution. Why would I expect anything less of the more complex designs in the universe and of life? :)
Because it's faster? Somewhere out there in the world is a tree with a branch that is perfectly shaped to be part of a hammer. But when I need a hammer I won't grow a billion trees and find the one with the best shaped branch, I'll take a slightly bigger branch and cut it in the shape I like. Here we come back to the fact that evolution takes many generation and it's essentially random, so IF you have the option of taking the role of an intelligent designer, that is often the quickest way to get stuff done.
There are many biologists and geneticists that don't believe in unguided, large-scale adaptation (evolution) as origin of all life. Many are in the intelligent design camp. So, you can't speak for all biologists and geneticists. Instead, I'm countering evolutionists since it's them biologists, geneticists, complexity theorists, and systems people (me) disagree with.
"If it was really such an easy ability to acquire you'd think that more than 1 of the 12 lines would have achieved it after 75k+ generations."
We believe in small-scale adaptations ("micro-evolution"). Things that turn something on or off in existing genetic code, like this example per my link, would fit in there. So would antibiotic resistance in bacteria. We still don't see them forming new organs or anything substantial like evolutionists say happened for most (all?) species on Earth.
Far as difficulty, we believe it's difficult. Actually, those of us opposing macro-evolution say that micro-evolution can be so hard for things like citrate that it furthers our doubt in their larger claims. Especially when the features have irreducible complexity at mind-boggling levels.
" the development of species over time with a fossil record and existing species that looks exactly like an evolutionary tree, including physical traits, similarity in genetics"
You all just describe it that way, like marketing. I've already noted that evolutionists usually believe in evolution a priori, come up with evolutionary explanations for anything they observe, ignore what is contrary to the theory, and publish what supports the general theory. They certainly present things in a way that looks like they evolved. Many specific examples they put forth in the past turned out to not be what they said, too.
Until the systemic bias is eliminated, I don't trust such presentations of cherry-picked data over observations of actual evolution. Further, the prior predictions of evolution didn't match the observations. They promoted it harder and made excuses instead of dropping it. Since then, we've learned the universe and body are even more complex than originally anticipated. Macro-evolution is provably harder than believed when evolution was failing its predictions.
Even as macro-evolution became harder, we saw people posit evolutionary algorithms with the Humies Awards as proof of its design. I was one of those people before becoming Christian because pro-evolution statements with those cherry-picked presentations were all I was ever exposed to. Now, I get to see several sides. In any case, re-reviewing the work on evolutionary algorithms and large, language models (eg GPT) show they take an enormous amount of intelligent design to accomplish anything useful. Everything from the substrate to the math to the implementation to the environmental interface.
" suggest that their ancestors may have had legs" "since apparently some muscles are still connected to them. But regardless of vestigiality, they're clearly remains of legs."
This is an example of what I'm talking about. They're actually just bones that look kind of like leg bones. So, that means they're either leg bones or that legs and those use a similar structure for a purpose. Instead of proof of structural similarity, you say it's proof of evolution because your worldview (evolution) dictates starting everything with its conclusions as premises. Even with muscle tissue, you have to think it's vestigial or a leg because evolution makes you want to.
Note: Interestingly, the Bible does have a serpent with legs that becomes a snake. That's presented as a supernatural event, though, so I can't use it here. Plus, it's testimony, not science.
"Does it sound like a grand conspiracy to you?"
It is if you call organizational bias a conspiracy. It's a fact that they wouldn't allow competing theories in most places. The person would be mocked, rejected by the journal, or not even get funded. With that happening, all research output is pro-evolution because those controlling the human processes are pro-evolution. Any science that becomes dogma with strong, political motivation is self-reinforcing.
"so IF you have the option of taking the role of an intelligent designer, that is often the quickest way to get stuff done."
Straight-forward creation is the fastest route for an intelligent designer capable of sustaining the whole universe. Ours can and did. Whether or not God worked through evolution from there is an open question.
Empirical observations of the only intelligent designers we know, humans, show they create their fictional universes rapidly before forcing things to happen with in-universe laws. Think filming a movie vs what happens in the movie's universe. Even in the fictional universes, they often say they were evolved because things look that way. They weren't. The whole thing was shot in months to a year. Truth is we can't know by internal observation.
If stating something obviously false, need some citation. As others in this thread have done, the religious are kind of used to making things up, so it seems ok to them. They can't detect false information as readily.
Let me show you an example where I can say anything.
"Most Creationist/Intelligent Designers, secretly believe in Science and Evolution, and know their beliefs are total bunk, and do not say out loud, because they are fearful of the other cult members ejecting them from their community. Or in some way bearing a stigma and being punished. So continue to spout the party line".
https://creation.com/creation-scientists
Answers in Genesis has a whole page on both profiles and biases against non-evolutionary scientists:
https://answersingenesis.org/creation-scientists/?gad_source...
I’ll also add there are billions of people who are Christian, Catholic, Muslim, or Hindu. Most are likely to reject atheistic materialism that’s a presupposition of evolution theory. It’s hard to tell who godless scientists speak for but it’s a minority. They’re a majority where they have power, though.
There is still a scale problem.
If the list has 700, out of 480,000. Then that is .15%
In any group, from any field, any skills. There are .15% crazy people. There could be .15% people that believe the world sits on a giant turtle. Or still believe in Zeus.
Ok. You are in deep with this belief. It can be scary to try and get out of a cult.
Do you have any logic, or reasoning, that Does Not Include the Bible, to explain why a god that created the entire universe, and the world, would cherry pick some tribes in the Middle East to provide his one true message. ?
Just because there are some unknowns, where is the leap to creationism and a Christian god. That is really just mysticism. People have always made up mystical reasons for he unknown. All of the same reasoning used for Creationism can also be used to say the universe was created by an Alien AI and set on top of a Turtle.
https://ncse.ngo/how-many-creationists-science
""“Newsweek found that less than 0.15% of 480,000 biologists and earth scientists polled doubted evolution.” The citation is to a June 29, 1987, story by Larry Martz with Ann McDaniel.
What Martz and McDaniel actually wrote, though, was, “By one count there are some 700 scientists with respectable academic credentials (out of a total of 480,000 U.S. earth and life scientist[s]) who give credence to creation-science, the general theory that complex life forms did not evolve but appeared ‘abruptly.’”""