"never write a reply that is against PG if you want to keep your karma point high."
Really? I'd expect pg himself, at least, to upvote a comment that gets him to think. I don't think I've tried yet the experiment of disagreeing with him directly. I'll observe the results if I do.
To answer the main question, I like comments that grapple with the main point of the post or comment to which they are replying, and especially comments that link out to useful resources on the same or a related subject.
A kind of comment I would like to see more of, a kind I have posted but don't get a lot of upvotes from, is asking a question along the lines of "How could we find out more about the facts of this issue?" or "What is the significance of this statement and its importance?" (You can see specific examples in the listing of my comments with low upvote totals. :) ) I really would like to know from the smart people here how they gather and evaluate evidence and how they make social policy trade-offs among competing interests.