This why your lion + tiger is not some special case, it trivially fails the definition: Their offspring are sterile.
Now ring species as you describe have not been shown to exist. Let me refer you as well to this brilliant article by an evolutionist explaining that: https://whyevolutionistrue.com/2014/07/16/there-are-no-ring-...
In short, the suspected ring species were found to produce fertile offspring when interbreeding at the ring-closing point (!).
> The authors [...] found, contrary to previous information, that there are indeed some hybrids (fertile ones, since they backcross) produced where the ring closes at the top, so they aren’t really acting like full biological species.
So we cannot be certain that where the ring closes, inter-breeding is impossible, because it has been shown to occur. Further:
> In the end, the authors conclude [...]: there are no good examples of ring species in nature
---
It's not about "doubting" in a religious sense. As an intellectual and academic I simply reserve the right to challenge and poke holes as rigorously as I can into any theory presented to me. What I found is that speciation-by-random-mutation appears to fail my (admittedly difficult but nonetheless valid) challenge.
As for plate tectonics: Look, if I were to say the evidence in my eyes does not support the theory well enough, would that make me unscientific? Of course not! The best counter-example I just posted are ring species - scientists once had extreme confidence in their existence, only to be disappointed after new findings.