> Centralization works and is highly preferable for many users.
I don't think users care about that at all, and if they have it explained to them, hate it. I think the real problem is that we haven't decentralized ownership and decisionmaking, instead we shattered big dictatorships into little fiefdoms, often run by local gangs (as one would expect.) Arguing that federation should automatically solve our problems with social media is like the US argument for "state's rights." You had one problem, now you have 50.
This is also exacerbated by the fact that people can't migrate. That would seem like it should be a developer priority to enable competition between instances, but instead people get irritated when asked about it at all. Every post locks you in farther to a particular instance. If people can leave on a whim, bad instances would starve. Instead of people being able to vote with their feet, the politics of mastodon all revolve around punishing other instances for various examples wrongthink by defederating. So now it's little fiefdoms at war with each other, you have to be in the in-crowd of your likely randomly chosen instance to have a say about it, and if you leave you lose everything.