You're trading the warm feeling of an illusion of trust for a total lack of awareness and protection against even the most mild attempt at obfuscation. This means that people who want to hurt or trick you, will have free reign to do it, even if it means your 90-year-old grandmother lacks the skill.
GDPR.
How many breaches of privacy by large orgnaizations occur in the EU? When they occur, what happens?
On the other hand - what's the story in the USA?
Alternatively what would have happened if we simply said "data privacy cannot be maintained, no laws will help"?
Consider any hacker from a non-extraditing rogue state.
Consider any nation state actor or well-equipped NGO. They are more motivated to manipulate you than Starbucks.
Consider the slavish, morbid conditions faced by foreign workers who manufacture your shoes and mine your lithium. All of your favorite large companies look the other way while continuing to employ such labor today, and have a long history of partnering with the US government to overthrow legitimate foreign democratic regimes in order maintain economic control. Why would these companies have better ethics regarding AI-generated output?
And consider the US government, whose own intelligence agencies are no longer forbidden from employing domestic propaganda, and whom will certainly get internal permission to circumnavigate any such laws, while still exploiting them to their benefit.
Malicious non-compliance is still common IME. Enforcement is happening but has been focused on the very large egregious abuse so far only.