I agree with everything you said. Leaving the morale and ideology aside for a moment though and looking at the technical side, couldn't this, at least in theory, also be implemented in a way that's not so dystopian? Everyone has a SIM card, whether physical or digital, and also a cell plan. If you make carriers mark all underage customers and then have the SIM forward that boolean value to the phone and nothing more, could you in theory still implement something like this without any further breach of privacy? Of course, as with any system there's workarounds, but as a baseline this would work, no?