Imagine a prosecutor, or a juror during deliberations: "He lied to police about not owning a gun, and he lied with a fake alibi about being somewhere else at the time. Those aren't the actions of an innocent bystander."
In practice, police will gladly make your life hell by charging you with obstruction of justice or a vague charge like disturbing the peace and let you sit in jail for a weekend until they drop the charges. There are countless ways in which they can mess with you, and they are legally unaccountable 99% of the time.
Better advice is simply do not engage with police, and know your rights.
The power dynamic is not even.
It’s better to invoke the fifth to state you don’t answer questions without legal representation.
Lying to a suspect under explicit custody, e.g. “your buddy in the next room confessed” is fine. Policing stops working when we pedantically construct it, which leads to a predictable backlash that stifles civil liberties—hard to be free if you’re dead. (And I’m assuming we don’t provide paper rights. If a Harvey Weinstein can raise reasonable suspicion someone was untruthful, he’s off.)
I'm very confused by your statements.
Various legitimate interrogation techniques rely on bluffing, e.g. exploiting the prisoner’s dilemma. In other cases, the cop may say something they thought was true but isn’t. Disentangling this admits the Fifth Amendment heavily tilts the table for the suspect.
> Alternate reading is that the cops can kill you?
Murder, in general, is illegal. Lying, in general, is not.
It’s the difference between saying ‘I’ve got the best car ever, it’s amazing!’, and ‘my car has a V8’ when it does not.
Sure. They’re not. They’re lying to get coöperation from criminal suspects for no financial gain. Similar but categorically different.
Should our diplomats be required to divulge state secrets if asked nicely? Even acknowledge them? This is HN—we’ve been proximate to or even held power, corporate potentially state. Policing is adversarial. No lying outside arrest, sure, but once in custody, the cops should be allowed to lie but not materially mislead you in respect of your rights. Anything else doesn’t work to the point that it gets replaced with popular backing.
Why is that legitimate?
I’m all ears!
He's saying that if police doesn't have some flexibility (like using such tricks to get a suspect to confess), criminals end up getting to roam free, and this, all other things being equal, ends in a way worse society than one where police is allowed to cheat suspects.