Not surprising at all - kaggle (as currently implemented) is a fundamentally broken model. On top of the rather unpleasant "everybody pays auction" or "winner take all" system, they have a severe problem with metrics - the majority of the datasets are not anywhere near large enough to give stable out of sample error estimates, which means that in many cases the "winners" are barely better than random.
Perhaps they might be onto something with "kaggle prospect", but unless they pivot in some creative new direction, it's hard to see the service being very useful.