Energy prices are set by the government and don't reflect the actual cost. French tax payers pay for the difference and have done so for years. The cost price probably excludes quite a bit that tax payers are also paying for.
The sad reality with nuclear is that it's a very unprofitable business unless you get governments to sponsor construction, waste disposal, security, etc. and then bail out failing nuclear companies when they fail anyway. All of these things have happened in France. France has nuclear reactors because it regards being a nuclear power as strategically important. Not because it's particularly cheap. It never was.
As of now, that somewhat artificial cost of 8 cents per kwh is actually on the high side for renewables. There are cheaper ways to get power these days.
Really? Aren't they getting life-extended past 40 years? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fessenheim_Nuclear_Power_Plant was closed down due to Swiss/German objections, but are any of the other PWRs planned to be closed down?
> French tax payers pay for the difference and have done so for years.
Social tariffs are a thing, as is redistribution of wealth.
> that somewhat artificial cost of 8 cents per kwh is actually on the high side for renewables
Let us not conflate the price paid to a generator with the cost to the consumer. Also why do renewables need subsidies in France? https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/files/docume...
https://www.enerdata.net/publications/daily-energy-news/fran...
> The full cost of existing nuclear power calculated by the CRE amounts to respectively €60.7/MWh over the period 2026-2030
And the first hit for "wind power cost europe mwhr" shows just how subsidized nuclear is:
https://windeurope.org/policy/topics/economics/
At its cheapest wind is half the cost of nuclear and at its worst is the same cost as nuclear - with none of the massive headaches.
Which is 6 euro cents per KWh. Fully in line with what I said.
French consumers are paying less for their electricity than, for example, Californians (https://www.cnet.com/home/energy-and-utilities/heres-the-ave...) where electricity largely comes from natural gas (https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/califo...).
>And the first hit for "wind power cost europe mwhr" shows just how subsidized nuclear is:
This source makes a vague claim about LCOE estimations not taking subsidies into account. It says nothing to establish the amount of those subsidies, or even to quantify the cost of any power source besides wind.
>with none of the massive headaches.
Onshore wind generation has plenty of drawbacks. Much of what's commonly said against nuclear is baseless fearmongering.
Ugh how long will it take for this to die?
If the answer is no, then the myth can die.
If the answer is yes, then it will survive until wind farms operators no longer seek to be exempted.
For example ensuring plants don’t get built in endangered bird habitats and rules concerning operation during endangered birds migratory periods.
Seems like you want wind power to fail, like nuclear is, and are attempting to sling any potential mud you can find.
So we should allow companies to operate unhindered within (evidence based) rules. Seems like an idea. Let us use that approach for all activities, including nuclear power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model is a model with scant evidence in the range relevant to operating a power station. Having said that the ICRP will be updating their model within a decade or so, so perhaps that barrier will disappear.
The entire industry would shut down tomorrow if they had to pay the true insurance cost.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price%E2%80%93Anderson_Nuclear...
The flip-side of the Price Anderson act is that the NRC is deeply involved in the operations of nuclear power stations.
Why stop at nuclear; why not aircraft, social networks or unvaccinated people? Also make all companies unlimited liability so their shareholders are accountable when something goes wrong.
Criticism is met with “don’t you dare question the subsidies” and then a stream of whataboutism across completely different industries rather than daring to compare with the alternative: renewables.
Because you already know that comparison makes the nuclear case even worse than it already is.
Renewables don’t have capped liability, at worst if regular insurance coverage is not enough the company will be bankrupted and the assets sold to pay for the damages.
For renewables it is already baked into the price because the risks are near zero.
Remind me how much each eagle is worth? How about power cuts caused by wind farms tripping incorrectly? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-49309691 How about disruption caused by failure to provide power in low wind conditions, or is that just a societal risk rather than investor risk?
Then more whataboutism. Typical.
How about the disruption caused by half the French nuclear fleet being offline at the height of the energy crisis?
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/15/business/nuclear-power-fr...
A recent study found that nuclear power needs to come down 85% in cost to be competitive with renewables when looking into total system costs for a fully decarbonized grid, due to both options requiring flexibility to meet the grid load. > The study finds that investments in flexibility in the electricity supply are needed in both systems due to the constant production pattern of nuclear and the variability of renewable energy sources. However, the scenario with high nuclear implementation is 1.2 billion EUR more expensive annually compared to a scenario only based on renewables, with all systems completely balancing supply and demand across all energy sectors in every hour. For nuclear power to be cost competitive with renewables an investment cost of 1.55 MEUR/MW must be achieved, which is substantially below any cost projection for nuclear power.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192...
https://www.npr.org/2022/04/06/1091250692/esi-energy-bald-ea...; around 30k USD per eagle. That's the cost of doing business, I guess.
> A recent study found that nuclear power needs to come down 85% in cost to be competitive with renewables when looking into total system costs for a fully decarbonized grid
Per paper you've linked to :-
For nuclear power to be cost competitive with renewables an investment cost of 1.55 MEUR/MW must be achieved
They state that for nuclear to be cost competitive with (per table 2) onshore wind (1.03 MEUR/MW, 0.37 capacity factor), offshore wind (1.90 MEUR/MW, 0.51 capacity factor) and solar (0.6 MEUR/MW, 0.14 capacity factor) it has to have a price between offshore and onshore wind. One also has to wonder why the high nuclear scenario has 9GW of intermittent energy sources in the mix.Supplementary material chart S1 reveals that the nuclear power is a small part of the overall cost of the energy system. "Transport costs", "remaining investments" and "Operations and maintenance" are over 20B of the 25B EUR cost per year. Figure 6 of the paper needs to be viewed with these totals in mind.
Supplementary material chart S3 shows they model nuclear's availability factor by smoothing outages across the year, only ever producing 6,686MW. EDIT :- actually it goes up to 6,823MW for part of the year, averaging out to 6,743MW.
Overall the paper is rather poor.
EDIT :- Looking at the S3 data again, it appears that heating and unflexible demand add up to at most 9,770MW, so only another 2 nuclear power stations would cover that peak.
Then you try to justify enormous nuclear costs because "it is not too bad" when comparing to what we already need to do.
You know there are similar costs today in the transportation system. Add up what we pay for fossil fueled ICEs and "it's not too bad!!!".
This is quite typical, a complete inability to accept reality calling anything not mindlessly promoting your precious nuclear power "poor".
So Denmark can not change its energy system from intermittents to nuclear because that's impossible, but it can change from fossil fuels to intermittents because it must be done? Given a 20 year lifetime for intermittents it should be possible to manage their phase-out.
> Then you try to justify enormous nuclear costs because "it is not too bad"
I did point out that the nuclear "is a small part of the overall cost of the energy system"; it is unclear how the authors have justified 80% of the system cost and how that varies with intermittency of energy supply and demand (e.g. reduced transmission cost, scope in the summer to use a excess electricity).
> a complete inability to accept reality
It is unfortunate that the model behind this is not available for peer study; https://www.energyplan.eu/atomkraft is not a live link and the archive.org version of this does not hold a copy of the scenario files. The results depend critically on the model used (and software used to solve it) so in the absence of further information all I can do is look at the results in the paper and point out obvious issues.
I've just spotted the cost modelling of the intermittents; rather than using IAEA LCOE data (or state LCOE directly), table 2 states costs in terms of capital, O&M as a percentage of investment and lifetime. Crunching their numbers (with a 3% interest rate) I come to offshore wind LCOE being 29.75 EUR/MWh, onshore wind 24.41 EUR/MWh and solar 33.44 EUR/MWh. This seems on the low side.
Do you believe that this paper is a good example of energy modelling?
Assuming that price is with a 77% capacity factor there is an easy way to reduce the cost per MWh; get them to run with a higher capacity factor. Finland has achieved 94% over the last few years, and the US is up at 93% I believe. https://pris.iaea.org/PRIS/CountryStatistics/CountryDetails....
Assuming that this is mainly fixed costs the price could be down to 60.7*.77/.94 = 50 EUR/MWh; fuel is a minor input and might bump the price up to perhaps 53 EUR/MWh.
No, we shouldn't. Pull up charts for energy generation by type for the US, Canada, and Europe. Notice that solar and wind (especially wind) has skyrocketed and far eclipsed the capacity loss of nuclear. In the US, 7 times as much wind power is going in as nuclear plants being taken offline. In the UK, 30% of power generation (and growing) is from wind.
Now, who do you think knows better here? The power companies who have been shutting down nuclear and coal plants because they're more expensive than wind and solar? Or...uh...you?
If your answer is "me", then clearly you should get a job in energy production, or become an investor, and make a bazillion dollars knowing more than everyone else in the industry, in nearly every country.
US, EU, UK...all seeing massive capacity growth in wind, far eclipsing nuclear decommissioning. Several countries have hit days in the last few years where they didn't need to have any fossil fuel plants online.
> indeed, there have been recent campaigns to revive old plants and step up production.
That is because the nuclear industry is lobbying desperately to stay alive.
If you need to lobby the government to force power companies to use you while also handing you a big fat check written by taxpayers, that is proof you're not market competitive.