Probability as Space
thebitfarm.blogspot.com
thebitfarm.blogspot.com
"A person has two kids, and his first-born is a boy. What is the probability the other is a boy?"
There are two possibilities, each equally likely -- (first-born, second-born): (B,B) and (B,G). Hence, 1/2.
"A person has two kids, and one is a boy. What is the probability the other is a boy?"
In other words: "The first-born is a boy AND/OR the second-born is a boy."
There are three possibilities, each equally likely -- (first-born, second-born): (B,B), (B,G), and (G,B). Hence, 1/3.
Others imagine -- (first-born, second-born): (B,B), (B,G), (G,B), hence 1/3.
Someone needs to write a blog post explaining why the latter method is superior, not just a blog post that automatically enumerates the four states.
People need a REASON for not combining BG/GB, and considering the children as (first-born, second-born) provides much of that reason, since it is a logical way of ordering children. A (one-child, other-child) ordering appears a bit absurd, even to the layperson.
People seem to be good at enumerating the "probability space" quite well. They just don't understand why the dimensions are what they are.