Hacker News Reader

Comment by bongodongobob | Hacker News Reader

It seems like this entire thread is a counterargument to your claim.

It's not a counterargument at all. It's just someone who assumes that there is this great counterargument they haven't bothered to make while whining "there are other bad songs too". Your comment here indicates that you're just too young to have heard it every single day, twice a day, throughout your childhood as it inexplicably got constant airtime. The long ride to and from school on the schoolbus, my first experience with torture. At least on sundays you could turn Solid Gold off. This is like saying "Vietnam wasn't that bad" because you watched a war movie once.

I'm in my 40s and loved it as a kid.

> ... heard it every single day, twice a day, throughout your childhood

If it was so terrible, why did it get played so often?

When I think "terrible", I think of the movie "The Room", which has been called the Citizen Kane of bad movies. It is truly awful. The dialog is awful. The acting is awful. There are all sorts of logical inconsistencies where things inextricably appear and disappear. By any metric it's bad. It's so bad that it has a cult following because it's so bad.

"We Built This City" just isn't anything like that.

Compare it to My Humps [1] or What Does the Fox Say [2] or Friday, just to name a few? These are a few random songs that are all miles worse than We Built This City.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iEe_eraFWWs

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jofNR_WkoCE

And they are still not even as bad as a lot of basically redundant modern pop with the deliberately atonal robovox, trap beats, and flat production.

I think you're conflating "overplayed" with "just plain bad."

Your comment here indicates that you're just too young to have heard it every single day, twice a day, throughout your childhood as it inexplicably got constant airtime.

So your argument is basically just a no true Scotsman.

I grew up listening to it. I still enjoy it. I also still enjoy Rock Me Amadeus, and Kashagoogoo's Never Ending Story theme, too.

I was ten. How old were you? I ask because your recollection has strong "seething teen" energy.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com