Hacker News Reader

I love how he’s claiming bias due to his critic’s employer. As though working for Google has no conflicts? A company that is desperately hyping each and every “me too” AI development to juice the stock price?

Jeff drank so much kool aid he forget what water is.

View on HN

He's criticizing Markov for not disclosing the conflict, not for the conflict itself. Hiding your affiliation in a scientific publication is far outside the norms of science, and they should be criticized for that. The publication we are discussing — "That Chip Has Sailed" — dismisses Markov in a few paragraph and spends the bulk its arguments on Cheng.

I know the norms of science, I also know norms of present day Google. Nobody from Google should have the gall to accuse others of anything.

Markov's article has been on arxiv since 2023 before the perceived conflict. https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09633 All his affiliations have been disclosed and likely known to Jeff Dean. Jeff is simply unable to respond to Markov's article in the technical dimension and is resorting to dirty tricks instead.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com