I think HN should implement the same restrictions as Reddit (Yes, I said it), nobody can change the title once the post has been submitted. This ensures consistency throughout the post's lifetime.
Actually, at this point I'd agree - I'd rather have immutable submitter-editorialized titles than editors butchering half the submissions.
Yep, exactly. I don't have a problem with editors fixing titles that are full of gratuitous spin or editorializing. But lately it seems that they're all but enforcing a policy of "every link must have the original page title and nothing else" and that's just silly.
Someone should try making a website like this, except use the upvotes and downvotes of its users to determine which titles and articles are worthy of being shown.