This all feels like a shakedown.
This all feels like a shakedown.
I don't trust anyone who claims to be absolutely certain on these types of questions. Same for "when does it stop being prediction and start being intelligence" or how many steps between there might need to be. I do trust those who feel one way is overall more advantageous for society even though they aren't precisely sure about the details though. Personally I've always had trouble with believing existing copyright laws are at the right balance for what's good for society anyways so I tend to lean towards the "let the data be used for training" side of things too. I just think the questions are even fuzzier than normal copyright questions rather than clearer.
The "trained on" isn't the law being broken here, that's the scare campaign. If it wins it's just the smoking gun that helps prove the other points easier, you'll still be able to train on anything.
But if the portion of some work thought to be there is not actually in the final product (prompt engineering a reproduction by detailed description shouldn't count as that is tracing with words) and it's just some style mix (as most AI engineer's say) then I don't think anything will come of this.